Republican Proposal for Failure

Burr’s boneheaded health proposal this week is simply one more exercise in Republican denial on real health reform.  Like President Bush – surprise, surprise – Burr proposes taxing health benefits everyone receives now through their employers.  To offset the increase in taxes some sort of credit or deduction would be offered.  This is an idea that’s been around for years

Many people don’t realize the money paid by their employer for health insurance is not considered as income and not taxed.  If it were suddenly counted as income, then people’s taxes would go up dramatically.  In addition, employers would have a huge incentive to stop offering coverage since it would no longer be subsidized through the tax system.

Let me just stop and say this – if Democrats were proposing this sort of reform can you imagine the talk radio shouts about “the largest tax increase in American history”?

The real goal for these so-called “reformers” is actually pretty simple – dismantle the employer system and have everyone buy coverage individually.  We already know that individual coverage is more expensive and far less efficient.  That’s why a large company pays far less for the same health coverage for its employees than if each one of those employees went to buy coverage on the individual market.

 Finally, there is an inescapable truth that makes this Bush-Burr type approach to health reform fairly dotty.  Health insurance is expensive and the reason most people who aren’t covered don’t have coverage is that it costs too much.  For some reason, this is hard for conservatives to admit.  In point of fact, it isn’t such a bad idea to at least explore changing the tax treatment of health benefits, but only if there is a comprehensive health plan in place like Medicare where anyone who fails to roll the dice and get “great coverage” in the private market can obtain reasonably-priced health benefits. 

 Until then, upping costs even more for people who are already covered makes no sense in any world except the desperate one Republicans currently find themselves in.


  1. Anglico

    July 28, 2007 at 8:28 pm

    You’re right. Brrrr’s plan is idiotic on every count.

    However, I’m all for dismantling the employer-based model and replacing it with a single program covering all citizens of North Carolina, regardless of their employment status, income, pre-existing conditions, or whatever.

    As long as we try to keep on foot in the employer-funded grave, the possibility of real reform is zero.

  2. […] Sen. Richard Burr’s co-sponsored bill that would provide tax credits for individuals and familes to purchase health insurance “would ensure every American has access to affordable, quality health insurance through the free market.” The Progressive Pulse is predictably upset, saying the “real goal for these so-called ‘reformers’ is actually pretty simple – dismantle the employer system and have everyone buy coverage individually.” Meanwhile, JLF’s Joe Coletti says the bill “will provide tremendous benefit for the uninsured, those who purchase insurance on their own, and people who have to pay extremely high premiums to get family coverage through their employers.” […]

Check Also

Senator Richard Burr: Makes up his own facts about NC Medicaid in order to criticize it

North Carolina’s Senator Burr used to be a ...

Top Stories from NCPW

  • News
  • Commentary

Veteran North Carolina education policy expert Kris Nordstrom has authored a new and vitally importa [...]

When Joni Robbins, a section chief in the N.C. Department of Public Instruction, closes bidding next [...]

Congress has just a few days left this month to enact legislation that would address the immigration [...]

12.2 million - the number of people nationally who signed up for health care coverage using HealthCa [...]

“All speech is free, but some speech is more free than others.” This seems to be the motto of the cu [...]

Trumpists prepare to raze another vital common good law It’s hard to keep up these days with the flo [...]

The post That’s how ‘Humbug’ is done appeared first on NC Policy Watch. [...]

The solid citizens of Johnston County, N.C. – in a fateful quirk of geography – for several years ha [...]

Featured | Special Projects

NC Budget 2017
The maze of the NC Budget is complex. Follow the stories to follow the money.
Read more

NC Redistricting 2017
New map, new districts, new lawmakers. Here’s what you need to know about gerrymandering in NC.
Read more