It’s The Hard Knock Life

AnnieI’m a little late commenting on the Sunday Times Week In Review because I was stopped dead by this: “You would not know, just as egg-yoke-colored glacier lilies are pushing through ground newly unburdened of its snow, that there is so much trouble around these lands that form America’s Best Idea.” (It’s corrected on the web.) I loves me some Timothy Egan, but I never yoke my eggs. Raw, they’re too runny and hard-cooked, they just won’t move. That field can’t plow itself, dammit.

Anywho, the point is Barbara Ehrenreich’s piece on how humiliating it is to apply for welfare these days. A neat trick, it’s kept people from applying for the help they desperately need.

Nationally, according to Kaaryn Gustafson, an associate professor at the University of Connecticut Law School, ‘applying for welfare is a lot like being booked by the police.’ There may be a mug shot, fingerprinting and long interrogations as to one’s children’s paternity. The ostensible goal is to prevent welfare fraud, but the psychological impact is to turn poverty itself into a kind of crime. …

It’s no secret that the temporary assistance program was designed to repel potential applicants, and at this it has been stunningly successful. The theory is that government assistance encourages a debilitating ‘culture of poverty,’ marked by laziness, promiscuity and addiction, and curable only by a swift cessation of benefits. In the years immediately after welfare ‘reform,’ about one and a half million people disappeared from the welfare rolls — often because they’d been ‘sanctioned’ for, say, failing to show up for an appointment with a caseworker. Stories of an erratic and punitive bureaucracy get around, so the recession of 2001 produced no uptick in enrollment, nor, until very recently, did the current recession. As Mark Greenberg, a welfare expert at the Georgetown School of Law, put it, the program has been ‘strikingly unresponsive’ to rising need.”

We’d like to thank you, Bill Clinton, for really showing us the way. We taught those welfare queens who’s boss, didn’t we? Only now, lots of people need help and we’re still treating them like scum. Food pantries are empty, cash donations are down, and the safety net is more onerous than generous. Is that who we are?

It brought to mind a PSA I keep hearing on KNC (or is it WSHA?) about the culture of secrecy that prevents citizens in high crime areas from cooperating with the police. Telling people that reporting crime isn’t “snitching” isn’t enough if we treat them like dirt when they need help. I know Raleigh needs to fight its burgeoning gang problem, but preaching at people who have more to fear from gang members than they can expect to hope from government officials is useless. Let’s think globally here, treat people like dignified human beings, and then ask for their cooperation. Let’s really reform welfare so that it’s a safety net, not a dehumanizing snare. We may get farther that way. We certainly can’t get much lower than treating needy folks like criminals because they dare to ask for help.


  1. Kimberly

    July 14, 2009 at 11:43 am

    I have to agree with the last paragraph. When a person applies for Welfare or Medicaid it is a humiliating experience. To have to swallow ones pride and ask for help is in itself embarrasing but then people are treated with disrespect and every part of their lives are questioned to see if they really deserve that help. The level of disrespect that one experiences does not stop after the application process has been completed, it carries on each time a person has to go through the verification or renewal process and each time they access any services that the public program covers. Our current system promotes family divisiveness and family financial hardship. It would be nice to have a system that actually promoted and supported family unity and helped people better their lives and their family.

  2. James

    July 14, 2009 at 12:28 pm

    You think it’s bad now? Wait till the half-assed “public plan” gets going. All those people who worried about a two-tiered system of health ain’t seen nothing yet.

  3. IBXer

    July 14, 2009 at 3:41 pm

    OH MY GOD!!! We live in a society in which people feel bad about being unemployed and dependent on others? What kind of people are we?!?!

  4. Chris

    July 15, 2009 at 12:45 am

    chick you spelled yolk wrong.

  5. Andrea

    July 15, 2009 at 8:45 am

    IBXer, that’s just how Jesus put it. Gandhi and the Buddha, too.

    Chris, that was the point, the New York Times spelled yolk wrong. In the Sunday paper. The N&O thoughtfully reprinted it this morning. And thanks for calling “chick” but I prefer “old lady”, just so you know.

Check Also

The drug war wins again

Mayor McFarlane made some good points in her ...

Top Stories from NCPW

  • News
  • Commentary

Conference comes a day after new report lauds benefits of same-day registration The new line-up for [...]

North Carolina’s largest public school system may be warning of “enormous disruptions” without speed [...]

Carol Turner hadn’t lived in North Carolina long before last November’s election. A retired nurse, s [...]

Controversy over class-size requirements in early grades has emerged as the biggest issue facing Nor [...]

The wisdom of the plan by Senate leaders to cut taxes by $839 million was called into question this [...]

Several years of tax cuts have not fixed our economic problems, and more of the same won’t either In [...]

Progress on “second chance” agenda marks a rare positive development in state policy wars There are [...]

24 million---the number of people in the United States who would lose health care coverage by 2026 u [...]

Featured | Special Projects

Trump + North Carolina
In dozens of vitally important areas, policy decisions of the Trump administration are dramatically affecting and altering the lives of North Carolinians. This growing collection of stories summarizes and critiques many of the most important decisions and their impacts.
Read more

HB2 - The continuing controversy
Policy Watch’s comprehensive coverage of North Carolina’s sweeping anti-LGBT law.
Read more