Is the State Health Plan fibbing about wellness savings?

Officials at the State Health Plan are now telling everyone that its draconian wellness initiatives will save $13 million in the first year.

Assuming that number is more credible than Executive Director Jack Walker’s PhD, where did it come from?

When Walker was first pushing the wellness proposals he told the General Assembly that he hoped the initiatives would break even after three years. And, to quote documents given to lawmakers during the legislative session:

Aon Consulting, consulting actuary for the Plan, estimates the smoking cessation program will save approximately $3.4 million in claims cost for the FY 2010-11. However, the administrative costs to begin implementation are estimated by Aon to offset any first year savings … Hartman and Associates, consulting actuary for the General Assembly’s Fiscal Research Division, does not project any financial impact to the Plan from the proposed smoking cessation program.

The rosiest projections we have so far say the state will not save money with the wellness initiatives. Where is the State Health Plan getting the $13 million figure from. Reporters should not recite the number without asking Walker.


  1. Phentermine

    September 23, 2009 at 10:26 am

    If everybody bought a trip to Disneyland once a year, then Disneyland could afford to charge a lower price for an annual pass. So those of you who don’t buy an annual pass or don’t buy a trip to Disneyland are ripping off responsible consumers. The only fair way out is for everybody to buy a trip to Disneyland or pay the equivalent in fines.

  2. AdamL

    September 23, 2009 at 10:41 am

    Nice try, but the hospital is no day at the park. Emergency rooms have to take everyone and my guess is that if you get hit by a car you’re not going to refuse intensive care just because you can’t cover the full cost. That means the costs are shifted to everyone else. That means if insurance is affordable you should buy it.

  3. EBB

    September 23, 2009 at 7:24 pm

    Great come-back, Adam L.

Check Also

Context is key for understanding Insurance Commissioner’s Affordable Care Act comments

Many people were surprised to see a story ...

Top Stories from NCPW

  • News
  • Commentary

Late March is prime spring planting season in North Carolina, and this year, as part of his personal [...]

The following collection of numbers comes from the 2018 North Carolina Child Health Report Card comp [...]

One-stop early voting for North Carolina’s May 8 primary election is a little over a month away, but [...]

A lone Southern yellow pine tree has stood in the middle of Marvin Winstead’s Nash County field for [...]

Ordinary Americans – those of us not allowed to know the secrets of high-level espionage work – at t [...]

Though they are sometimes dressed up in prettified language about “freedom” and “choice” and “market [...]

The post The apple doesn’t fall far from the tree appeared first on NC Policy Watch. [...]

In the aftermath of recent action by state lawmakers to back down from their previously enacted unfu [...]