Another Bob Greczyn claim goes to the truth-o-meter

imagesWe certainly can’t point out every lie told by Blue Cross and Blue Shield of North Carolina — there just aren’t enough hours in the year. But what about this claim by Greczyn:

This argument ignores the reality that insurance premiums have to rise in concert with mounting health care costs and increasing demand for the things insurance pays for: hospital stays, drugs, medical devices and diagnostic testing.

In other words, rising premiums are not the fault of private insurance companies.

Ezra Klein has an interesting chart today provided by Kaiser Permanente CEO George Halvorson that shows the steep prices our citizens pay for every medical test and procedure — and that is ignoring the volume of tests we receive. These tests and procedures and hospital stays cost more because of private insurance.

Medicare makes reimbursement recommendations based on wide ranging studies of how much care costs at efficient, high-quality hospitals around the country in urban and rural settings. It studies academic medical centers, teaching hospitals, and non-teaching hospitals. It then determines how much those efficient, high-quality hospitals need to make per procedure from Medicare.

Private insurance sets its payment rates by negotiating with hospitals, and Blue Cross Blue Shield of North Carolina is constrained only by the market power of the hospital and how much it can pass on to customers in the form of premium hikes. Because Blue Cross is a near monopoly insurance company it can pass on a great deal of costs to policy holders.

If a big hospital wants to put two flat screen televisions in every room, install hardwood floors, construct man made lakes and other amenities that don’t improve patient care, that overhead is passed on as “costs”. Blue Cross, as long as it can increase premiums, pays the hospital extra for those extra costs.

Certainly some premium increases are driven by the underlying cost of care. But Greczyn’s claim that private insurance companies are just passively reacting to the market is bogus at best.


  1. Adam Searing

    November 2, 2009 at 3:56 pm

    Bottom line here – private insurers, at least as currently structured in the US since many other countries have private insurers too, are not very good at negotiating the lowest prices for their customers. Just one more argument for reform.

  2. Alex

    November 2, 2009 at 4:10 pm

    When the top ten Executives at BCBSNC are making as much as they are I do not buy it.

    Health care reform or no next year my rates and out of pocket cost will rise way more than our income next year.

    Even with State Plan under BCBSNC I can’t afford the luxury of an ER visit or Hospital stay. I can only afford the basics even though we are spending 60% of our income on my health care.

  3. JohnInCA

    November 2, 2009 at 4:53 pm

    Gotta love the coverage of Kaiser. That would be the same miraculous “not-for-profit” health plan that had a $1B+ profit in the first half of this year, had a brilliant EMR project that went $4.2B over budget, had it’s kidney transplant program shut down by the state of California (which is remarkable… as CA’s state government is apparently afraid of Kaiser), and was also busted dumping it’s patients on LA’s Skid Row.

    I’m still puzzled why anyone listens to Kaiser. Their business model is obvious… get the person’s money for care on a pre-paid basis, and then deny, deny, deny (through all sorts of carefully designed & implemented obstructions).

  4. Single Payer Action

    November 3, 2009 at 7:30 am

    premiums are rising in part because more baby boomers are cresting over 50 everyday and are developing chronic health problems. Overlay that on top of the perverse incentives of fee-for-service reimbursement and you have a prescription for insolvency

Check Also

Context is key for understanding Insurance Commissioner’s Affordable Care Act comments

Many people were surprised to see a story ...

Top Stories from NCPW

  • News
  • Commentary

On a sultry day last September, Megan Stilley arrived at Lanier Farms, a large swine operation in ru [...]

When North Carolina lawmakers approved what one Republican described as a “historic” investment in r [...]

Lawmakers late last week released two new versions of a judicial redistricting bill, making these th [...]

An omnibus bill alleviating some of the headaches associated with North Carolina’s class size crisis [...]

The General Assembly’s latest mashup legislation is an example of government at its worst In the com [...]

The post Tied up in knots appeared first on NC Policy Watch. [...]

Every day brings new reports that Congress is interested in further whittling away at the programs c [...]

When Congress finally passed a continuing resolution last month allowing the government to re-open, [...]

Upcoming Events

Friday, Feb. 16

12:00 PM

Crucial Conversation – Prof. Peter Edelman discusses his new book, Not a Crime to be Poor: The Criminalization of Poverty in America

Prof. Edelman is coming to the Triangle to mark the 50th anniversary of Durham-based nonprofit MDC. His visit is the first of a series of MDC-sponsored events focused on ways that Southern leaders can work together to create an Infrastructure of Opportunity that shapes a South where all people thrive.”