Uncategorized

NC Justices: Suspended kids don’t have right to alternative schooling

In a batch of rulings released this afternoon, the N.C. Supreme Court decided that public schoolchildren suspended from classes don’t have a constitutional right to alternative education.

The ruling came down in two major educational law cases that had been pending before the court, King v. Beaufort Court Board of Education and Harvey-Barrow v. Beaufort County. In February 2008, a series of fights had broken out in a Beaufort County high school and two high school girls were suspended for five months, the rest of the school year, without an offer of an alternative school to attend. For more background on the case, check out this previous News & Observer article.

Several educational and civil rights groups, including the N.C. Justice Center, had weighed in on the case, arguing that suspending children for long periods of time without offering them any alternative education denies their right to a “sound basic education.”

The N.C. Supreme Court didn’t agree with that in today’s 4-3 opinion, written by N.C. Justice Mark Martin, instead finding that the constitutional right to a sound education is lost when a student misbehaves. (UPDATE: The other justices joining in Martin’s majority were Chief Justice Sarah Parker and Justices Edward Brady and  Robert Edmunds Jr.)

We decline plaintiff’s invitation to create a constitutional right to alternative education for students who violate lawful school rules.

The justices did offer a small consolation, however, offering a right to know why they’re suspended.

Because exclusion from alternative education potentially infringes on a student’s state constitutional right to equal educational access, school administrators must articulate a reasons when they exclude a long-term suspended student from alternative education.

Consenting in part and dissenting in part was Justice Patricia Timmons-Goodson, who took sharp aim at the decision made by her colleagues. Joining her was Robin Hudson.

No school system in the State of North Carolina can deprive students of all state-funded educational opportunities, unless it is absolutely necessary. I believe the Constitution of North Carolina and precedent from this Court made this guarantee to the children of our state. Today’s decision retreats from that promise.

Going even further in dissent was Justice Paul Newby, who felt that, not only did a student lose the right to an education once they were suspended, but that the courts shouldn’t second-guess the authority of a school system by offering a route to review a suspension.

Thoughts about today’s ruling? Please share.

UPDATE: It’s important to note that today’s ruling does give an intermediate level of court scrutiny in cases of long-term suspensions. That means decisions to suspend for long periods without an offer of alternative school can be reviewed by  a person outside of the school system.

One Comment


  1. Adam Linker

    October 8, 2010 at 1:59 pm

    What has Justice Parker been doing lately?

Check Also

UNC Board of Governors face protest, chooses new board chair and interim president

It was a busy day at the final ...

Top Stories from NCPW

  • News
  • Commentary

Two groups seeking state contracts to run struggling North Carolina schools have professional ties t [...]

North Carolinians will lose their “precious right to vote,” as U.S. Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader [...]

Saturday nights at the 311 Motor Speedway in rural Pine Hall smell of fast food and fuel. Wooden ble [...]

Cornelius Redfearn, principal at Durham’s Glenn Elementary, said Tuesday night that the looming unce [...]

The post NCAA Legitimacy Deflated appeared first on NC Policy Watch. [...]

There are lots of reasons for people to get off of the sidelines and commit themselves to new and su [...]

4---number of days since The Trump administration announced its decision to halt cost-sharing subsid [...]

Hypocrisy in politics is hardly a new phenomenon but rarely is it as boldly on display as it was las [...]

Featured | Special Projects

NC Budget 2017
The maze of the NC Budget is complex. Follow the stories to follow the money.
Read more


NC Redistricting 2017
New map, new districts, new lawmakers. Here’s what you need to know about gerrymandering in NC.
Read more