A not-so-Happy Anniversary

Today marks the 15th anniversary of the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) block grant, also known as “welfare reform”.

In 1996, under the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act (PWRORA), TANF replaced such welfare programs as Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC) and ended federal entitlement to assistance.

The idea behind welfare reform at the time, of course, was to end families’ dependence on AFDC and create a program that would move families into work and economic security.  TANF was established in the form of a block grant that provides states, territories, and tribes federal funds each year, with the majority of funds in North Carolina going towards programs like child care, foster care, and adolescent pregnancy prevention.

The remaining TANF funds go to North Carolina’ Work First program, the only remaining cash assistance program post-Welfare Reform.  Work First was established to assist extremely low-income families in becoming economically self-sufficient through basic services, a small cash grant, and short-term training.

Now, as we reflect back over the last fifteen years, it appears that TANF has achieved one of its major goals—that of dramatically decreasing the number of low-income families on traditional public assistance.

Yet, it has generally failed in its second and more important goal—helping families escape poverty and build economic security.

There’s no more telling indicator of this than looking at how TANF has responded to The Great Recession.

As a recent report from The Urban Institute shows, North Carolina’s unemployment rate has jumped by 97 percent since 2007, a sure sign of the great stress that the current recession has put on our state’s economy and families.

Yet during the same time period, the number of North Carolina families receiving TANF -Work First has actually declined by 4 percent.

In good economic times, a declining TANF caseload could be taken to indicate greater economic well-being.  That is, fewer families would appear to be in poverty and therefore eligible for or enrolled in a program like TANF-Work First.

But with unemployment at 10.1 percent in North Carolina and likely to go up more, we’re obviously not in good times and a lot of people are hurting.

One of the main reasons TANF has played such a limited role in building economic security and particularly serving as a life-line during the Great Recession is that for the program to work, there must be jobs.

To be eligible for Work First, recipients must be pursuing work, either in the form of receiving job training and/or by embarking on an extensive job search.  And after a limited amount of time, the cash benefits run out.  With the assumption being that once Work First recipients complete the program, get on their feet with a new set of skills, they’ll be able to find a job and will no longer need public assistance.

That model doesn’t work so well when it’s not just the very-poor struggling to find work.  North Carolina has lost more than 320,000 jobs from December 2007 to February 2010, when unemployment hit its lowest mark.
Moreover, TANF’s flaws aren’t just evident in hard times.  Poverty has actually gone up since Welfare Reform was implemented.  And deep poverty has especially increased.

Which all begs the question—shouldn’t we change TANF and find a better way to build economic security and decrease poverty?

If you think so, better contact your member of Congress.  That’s where the conversation will have to start.



  1. Taxed

    August 22, 2011 at 8:29 pm

    Let’s run the real numbers:
    Since the mid 60’s we have spent $16 Trillion on means tested government income re-distribution programs. We are now $14.4 Trillion in debt and have
    – 45 million people on food stamps,
    – over 40 million kids getting free school lunches,
    – 9 million more on WIC,
    – about 8 million in subsidized housing,
    – 5 million on TANF,
    – 8 million on SSI (including 1.2 million kids),
    – about 49 million on Medicaid and
    – 71 million households (47%) not paying income taxes primarily because of EITC and the Child Tax Credit.
    Does anybody really think more debt or taxes to pay for more income re-distribution programs is really going to help anything? We already have 70 programs now.
    How can a tax system be called “fair” when 47% of households are getting a free ride on the backs of the 53% who are paying income tax and carrying their own weight in society? What part of that is sustainable? What part of that is fair?
    All the corporations combined have never received this much of the taxpayers money. The cost of all the wars this country has ever fought doesn’t come close to this massive shift of wealth.
    It seems like the more we pay people to be poor, the more poor people we have. The above numbers prove that beyond any argument. And no – I am not wealthy, just sick and tired of paying other people’s bills while the poor folks keep crying “woe is me” and their “benefits” just keep growing and getting passed from generation to generation.
    It is going to take individual responsibility and millions of decent paying jobs to get us out of this mess, not more government intervention.

  2. Ricky

    August 23, 2011 at 9:26 am

    If being poor is as great as you say it is and that people in poverty are being favored and given “free rides,” then why don’t you go give it a try and we’ll talk later?

  3. david esmay

    August 23, 2011 at 11:43 am

    I’m not wealthy, but if the taxes I pay help those less fortunate, I’m glad to contibute. Each year as my kids grew up and left home our taxes increased,we don’t begrudge that fact. It’s a price I’m willing to pay for living in this country, just like my military service and my father’s, uncles, grandfathers, cousins, and so on. What I am sick of is this me, me, me whining.

Check Also

Falling Behind: State funding for early care & education plummets

Despite a contracting economy over the course of ...

Top Stories from NCPW

  • News
  • Commentary

The lump started small and hid behind her ear. Harmless, the doctor said, nothing to worry about. So [...]

The Senate voted along party lines Tuesday night to overturn a partial judicial redistricting bill i [...]

Viola Williams has been crunching numbers and working out possible solutions since last week, when t [...]

With midterm elections around the corner, lawmakers have, unsurprisingly, taken aim at last minute c [...]

From 1999-2016, opioid-related overdose fatalities increased by more than 800 percent in North Carol [...]

Would that North Carolina lawmakers had been so direct as “Pitchfork Ben” Tillman, a virulent white [...]

“I’m speechless.” So began the heartfelt lament of Rep. Verla Insko (D-Orange) late last Friday afte [...]

The post SB 711 – The pig’s roast appeared first on NC Policy Watch. [...]