New Policy Watch news story shows the “genius of the market” at work in education

Cameron Creek Charter SchoolAnyone who pays any attention to the debate over public education knows the rap consistently advanced by the pro-vouchers/pro-privatization crowd: “We need to bring the ‘genius’ of the free market to education so that schools will compete with each other and thereby drive up the overall quality of education.” This is the same argument under which charter schools are supposed to be “incubators of innovation” that hatch all sorts of brilliant ideas that then percolate  throughout the K-12 system.

A key and obvious flaw in this logic, of course, is its blind and absurd glorification of the private sector. Here’s the real truth about the “free market” in the U.S.: For all of its many strengths as a wealth producer, it is also frequently a ruthless and cutthroat world in which most new enterprises fail and in which many actors are driven by (and act upon) less-than-honorable motives — most notably greed.

To see evidence of this hard reality in North Carolina’s just-underway move to bring market forces to bear upon K-12 education, check out this story by NC Policy Watch reporter Sarah Ovaska: “Charlotte charter founders accused of plagiarizing, school may not open.”  

It turns out that a new charter school applicant in Charlotte basically lifted the language in its application, word for word, from another applicant. And what is perhaps even more disturbing, the harried and overworked people in the Department of Public Instruction’s Charter School Office (staff size: 6) didn’t even catch the plagiarism until it was called to their attention (and, indeed, had already given the applicant preliminary approval to open this August!). 

Ovaska also reports that a member of the proposed charter school board — a lawyer from Pennsylvania named Melvin Sharpe — was disbarred last September for misuse of client funds.   

Ovaska’s story, of course, comes less than two weeks after her in-depth report about a troubled Winston-Salem charter that is running  a basketball factory for foreign students.  

The bottom line: While there may be room for a small number of rigorously observed charter school laboratories in a healthy public education system, Ovaska’s story provides new confirmation of the lunacy of the notion we can upgrade North Carolina’s public schools by turning our system into some kind of dog-eat-dog, survival-of-the-fittest free market .

What we are doing by privatizing our schools and “unleashing the genius of the market” is flashing a giant open invitation to all sorts of people and institutions of widely varying degrees of competence and appropriateness: solid citizens and incompetent bumblers; well-meaning parents and shady con artists; worthy nonprofits and greedy corporations.  We are, in effect, premising our public education system upon the idea of widespread failure. And while such a model may work well when it comes to producing widgets or commodities, it is not a model upon which to base the development of young minds.


  1. JeffS

    February 14, 2013 at 5:23 pm

    You’re still basing your argument on the misguided notion that the right actually wants to educate everyone.

    The talking points are only there to convince the flock. No one in power actually believes it. The same is true for virtually every subject they bring to the table.

    Objective 1: Turn goverment money into corporate profit. Look no further than the boards and shareholder of private schools and corporate education companies for evidence.

    Objective 2: Train workers, not thinkers. Neoliberal education policy is nothing but a rehash of fascist education policy. If the countless scholarly papers on the subject are too dry, pick up an Orwell book on the way home. The parroting of the party line by people like McCrory, or should I say duckspeak, has little to no thought behind it. That only goes to prove my point though. The ideas are coming from higher up.

  2. James Protzman

    February 14, 2013 at 7:16 pm

    @Jeff “Like”

    It’s a hard truth, but a truth nonetheless. That’s one reason I’ve given up grounding any argument in an accusation that they’re being hypocritical. They are not being hypocritical. They are being true to their murderous, gluttonous, rapacious selves.

  3. love my state

    February 15, 2013 at 8:55 am

    ^^ “like” to both you guys!!

  4. david esmay

    February 15, 2013 at 8:32 pm

    The Right only wants to profit from education, they want to create an expensive, and yet increasingly inferior public educational system that from which they can shift taxpayer dollars in the form of vouchers to private schools, whose owners contribute to their campaigns.

Check Also

Policy Watch takes home seven NC Press Assn. awards; Sorg wins prestigious freedom of information honor

The reporting and commentary team at NC Policy ...

Top Stories from NCPW

  • News
  • Commentary

Any protection the courts offer Dreamers is temporary, but all eyes are on the U.S. Supreme Court to [...]

The good news is that the levels of GenX in Wilmington’s drinking water is testing consistently belo [...]

This week NC Child and the NC Institute of Medicine release the 2018 Child Health Report Card, an an [...]

North Carolina’s public school system is one of the lowest funded in the nation when adjusted for co [...]

In “Lessons on political speech, academic freedom, and university governance from the new North Caro [...]

Cracks are forming in the NRA’s death grip on American politics At some point, it’s going to happen. [...]

As the General Assembly wraps up its weirdly timed and generally ill-conceived winter session, it wo [...]

The post Dumb & Dumber & Dumbest appeared first on NC Policy Watch. [...]