NC Budget and Tax Center

How a supposed tax cut can still equal an overall loss

This is the fifth of a six-part blog series. (See Part 1, Part 2, Part 3, and Part 4)

What would the House tax plan mean for North Carolina taxpayers? In this blog series we highlight the experience of sample taxpayers under the House tax plan. In conjunction with a distributional analysis of the tax plan which gives a better picture of the full impact, these fictional but true to life profiles will demonstrate that middle-, fixed- and low-income taxpayers would lose under this plan while the wealthiest will gain. 

How a supposed tax cut can still equal an overall loss

Bob and Sue are married with an infant and toddler. Bob teaches 2nd grade at the local public school and Sue stays at home to take care of their two young children. With Bob’s salary as a teacher, they make about $46,000 a year. They often feel like they’re struggling to afford the necessities and live paycheck to paycheck. They aren’t able to go out to eat or take trips with the kids, but they are able to provide the necessities.

Under the House tax plan, Bob and Sue would see their tax load go down by about $63, or about 2 percent compared to current tax laws. When the couple becomes aware of this slight reduction in their tax load, they aren’t very excited because they have also been following the state budget debate and know that their oldest child, who they thought would be eligible for Pre-K services, would no longer qualify due to budget cuts that would have to be enacted to pay for the tax cuts. So they would have to pay about $8,000 a year for preschool. While Sue does stay at home currently, she wants her child to have a quality early education experience and be around other children her age to help prepare her for Kindergarten.

The family would have a tough decision to make: sacrifice the educational experience of their child, or sacrifice about $8,000 a year (17% of their annual income) to pay for preschool for their oldest child. On top of that, Sue has been attending classes at the local community college and notices that the budget proposal, if passed, would increase her tuition bill, meaning even higher family expenses. Bob would also be impacted by the budget cuts because he would see the number of students in his class increase and lose a teacher assistant. He loves his students and is concerned about how his ability to teach and the quality of his students’ education would be affected by these cuts.

Check Also

NC Senate proposal would expand the sales tax

Correction, posted May 19: The Budget and Tax ...

Top Stories from NCPW

  • News
  • Commentary

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled Monday that the North Carolina GOP drew unconstitutionally racially ger [...]

As the N.C. House puts together its budget this week, the same thought is on the minds of representa [...]

Wednesday was the 63rd anniversary of the Brown v. Board of Education ruling, the milestone U.S. Sup [...]

So, the question as always comes down to one of vision. The elected chieftains who decide how much m [...]

2.8 billion---amount in dollars of needs in communities across the state for rebuilding efforts from [...]

The post Crumbs appeared first on NC Policy Watch. [...]

In the past few months, North Carolinians have seen our General Assembly make national news several [...]

Featured | Special Projects

Trump + North Carolina
In dozens of vitally important areas, policy decisions of the Trump administration are dramatically affecting and altering the lives of North Carolinians. This growing collection of stories summarizes and critiques many of the most important decisions and their impacts.
Read more


HB2 - The continuing controversy
Policy Watch’s comprehensive coverage of North Carolina’s sweeping anti-LGBT law.
Read more