Democracy NC leader on Senate’s voter ID bill

Bob Hall, Executive Director, Democracy North Carolina, released the following statement this afternoon on the Senate’s new voter ID bill:

“The state Senate released its version of H-589, the photo ID requirement bill today. A comparison of some features with the House version is below.

The Senate bill takes a double swipe at college students, making it harder for them to vote. It refuses to accept student IDs from any college; the House at least accepts those from the UNC and community college systems. And it restricts the use of an out-of-state driver’s license to 90 days from the day of becoming a NC registered voter; the House accepts the out-of-state driver’s licenses as a legitimate government-issued photo ID. These are unnecessary, mean-spirited changes that target and punish college students who want to participate in the civic life of their college community.

The Senate version keeps a House provision that will make the NC law one of the most restrictive in the nation – harsher than the ones in Florida, Idaho, Michigan and several other states with a photo ID requirement. Those states allow the voter who lacks or forgets to bring the photo ID to sign an attestation under penalty of perjury and, in some cases, provide an identifying number, such as a birth date or Social Security number, that the board of elections can verify before counting the ballot. The proposed NC law would make that voter come back another day and show the correct ID to have their provisional ballot count.

This is significant: 70% of North Carolina voters say our law should also have that back-up provision for the voter without an ID who signs the attestation and gives an identifying number. A recent poll by the League of Women Voters of NC found that 75% of voters think a photo ID requirement is a good idea, BUT 70% also agree that the NC law should have the back-up provision rather than making the voter come back a second time to show an ID. Here’s the information from that poll. It also shows that when the proposed law disadvantages a group, such as students or seniors, public support drops way off:


These two versions do not improve confidence in elections. They manipulate the rules to discourage certain types of voters for a partisan advantage.

Here is preliminary comparison of the Senate version of H-589 to the version passed by the House shows. The Senate version:

** Cuts in range of acceptable photo IDs:

     > NO college student IDs are acceptable (House allowed NC public universities and community college ID)

     > NO out-of-state driver’s license is acceptable unless you’ve just recently registered to vote (i.e., less than 90 days before the election where you’re showing your ID). House allowed government photo IDs created by other states.

     > NO North Carolina county or municipal government or public employee IDs is acceptable

     > NO photo ID issued by a public assistance agency is acceptable – another slap at low-income voters

     > House allowed expired photo ID to be used, up to 10 years after expiration. But Senate version only allows the other House exception: a voter over 70 can use an expired photo ID for any length of time if it was current when they were 70.

** Cuts in education outreach:

     > NO advisory board, as in House, to advise State Board of Elections about strategies and partner groups to use in a comprehensive education program about the ID requirement

     > NO provision for additional staff at State Board to do education

     > NO reference to using the Voter Guide to include information about ID

** Makes small changes to provisions in House version for voters in nursing/rest homes to get assistance for applying for absentee ballots.”




  1. ML

    July 18, 2013 at 4:19 pm

    What about the provision where the parents of a college student that registers to vote in another county can no longer claim that child as a dependent?

  2. Jack

    July 18, 2013 at 5:16 pm

    In Kansas you need your birth certificate to get your state photo ID but to get your birth certificate you have to show a state photo ID.

    Is it voter suppression or building confidence in the voting system? Even Republicans are openly admitting that voter ID is voter suppression. There’s no longer an effort to pretend that without manipulation of voters at the polls they are unable to maintain their ideological stronghold.

    It isn’t about politics anymore it’s about ideology. An ideology that thrives on implementing segregation, restricting women’s rights, increasing the tax burden on people with low and fixed income and working poor families, dismantling the public school system, misappropriating public money to charter schools, denying services to people with special needs, supporting predatory lending and as of July 1 removing unemployment support. The list goes on and on.

    The ideologues continue to make it clear who is worthy and who is not.

  3. lawrence aiello

    July 19, 2013 at 1:35 am

    why are the idiot’s trying to ruin america ?

  4. Will

    July 19, 2013 at 8:49 am

    Only one word to describe these people: Hateful

  5. AnneP

    July 19, 2013 at 1:47 pm

    Let’s help John Lewis and others in Congress pushback on the Voter Registration Act–maybe that will help straighten out these idiots in NC. In fact, since protests and calls and letters to the NC legislature seem not move them that seems to be our only answer.

  6. Skeptic

    July 19, 2013 at 9:16 pm

    Republicans are stinking bags of hate. I profoundly hope Hell exists because they will burn and rot and suffer there for eternity.

  7. Frances Jenkins

    July 21, 2013 at 11:37 am

    The GOP is doing exactly what they were elected to do. Democrats are having a difficult time giving up power. They have resorted to attempts to destroy the Republican Party at all cost. That process begins with massive misinformation. May those that lie sit on a burnt stump in hell.

  8. Ken Glick (EEI)

    July 22, 2013 at 3:41 pm

    What I would like to know is where do you Republicans get the idea that there is widespread illegal immigrants voting in North Carolina from? If they show me some evidence that illegals are actually voting (not simply registering), then I’ll be 100% in favor legislation requiring picture ID before you can vote.

Check Also

The best editorial of the weekend

In case you missed it, the Greensboro News ...

Top Stories from NCPW

  • News
  • Commentary

Numerous questions remain, however, about the treatment of dozens of other trans inmates Kanautica Z [...]

The Trump Administration’s new public charge rule will do more to keep families separated than it wi [...]

GIBSONVILLE -- The tobacco fields near East Guilford High School are reminders of times bygone when [...]

They clutter the gutters and girdle the turtles. They snag in the trees and float in the seas.  Plas [...]

It can’t have escaped many folks’ notice – even those, bless their hearts, for whom the really big n [...]

Today we wait. We wait for the judges, who retired to their chambers weeks ago in the Common Cause v [...]

There was a fascinating exchange regarding North Carolina’s ongoing budget stalemate last week at a [...]

The post Red Flag laws versus White Flag lawmakers appeared first on NC Policy Watch. [...]