No choice on National School Choice Week

This week should not pass without acknowledging that it is “National School Choice Week.” This is the week described by its proponents as a way to shine a “positive spotlight on the need for effective education options for all children.” By this, these folks usually mean charter schools and vouchers.

The truth, however, is that evidence shows that these are not effective options at all. Nationally, the majority of charters either perform about the same as or worse than traditional public schools. The news is no better with vouchers. In places that have had vouchers the longest, public school students actually outperform students who receive private school vouchers on proficiency exams.

Even more fascinating than the illusion of choice that is being celebrated is the fact that there are people without choices when it comes to public education. The North Carolina General Assembly is constitutionally mandated, meaning they have no choice but to support the traditional public schools.

Article I, Section 15 of the North Carolina Constitution states that “the people have the right to the privilege of education, and it is the duty of the State to guard and maintain that right.” If that provision is not strong enough, the drafters of the constitution also state in Article IX, Section 2 that “[t]he General Assembly shall provide by taxation or otherwise for a general and uniform system of free public schools…” Clearly, our legislature is given the directive to provide funding to have a uniform system of public schools. In fact, taxation is included in the section in case the General Assembly needed to find a revenue source. The edict is obvious; fund public education.

Unfortunately, this General Assembly has chosen to fund private schools through vouchers called “Opportunity Scholarships.” The North Carolina Justice Center and the North Carolina Association of Educators (NCAE) filed a lawsuit partly based on another constitutional provision. Article IX, Section 6 requires that all money for public education should be faithfully appropriated and used exclusively for “establishing and maintaining a uniform system of free public schools.”

All of this means that the legislature cannot drain money from public education to provide vouchers to unaccountable private schools. They do not have that choice.

Those who support vouchers, including members of the General Assembly, use the refrain that public schools are “failing” and that, therefore, parents need choices. The truth is that if legislators lived up to their constitutional responsibilities, they would not present this illusory promise to desperate parents, but rather would ensure that schools were adequately and equitably funded for each student in North Carolina.

The solution is not unaccountable charter schools or the privatization of public education through vouchers. The answer is funding best practices like alternative assessments, extended learning time, professionalizing the teaching profession and interventions for at-risk students like Personal Education Plans. The aforementioned ideas require money — money that should not be deposited in what amount to unconstitutional and unaccountable education black holes.

As some celebrate National School Choice Week, we should continue to remind this General Assembly that they do not have the freedom to spend public money on unproven methods of education. When it comes to providing genuine (rather than illusory) opportunity to the state’s children, they do not have a choice.


  1. Tim Peck

    January 30, 2014 at 12:38 pm

    In a 2006 study, David Roland of the Institute for Justice found that private school choice would not violate the North Carolina Constitution.


  2. gregflynn

    January 30, 2014 at 2:01 pm

    Roland, then just 2 years out of law school, said “a well-crafted school choice program is extremely likely to survive judicial scrutiny under the relevant provisions of the state and federal constitutions.” and “North Carolina’s courts have interpreted the state’s constitutional provisions in such a way that there should be no constitutional impediment to a well-crafted school choice program.” It wasn’t a blanket statement about the constitutionality of private school choice, nor even the opinion of a constitutional expert.

  3. LayintheSmakDown

    January 30, 2014 at 6:36 pm

    So really, there is no harm in vouchers or choice is what you are saying. At a minimum we are in the same place at the end of the day so no harm no foul. This is just liberal hysteria at taking a little bit of control away from the government.

  4. gregflynn

    January 31, 2014 at 9:49 am

    I’m not saying it. The “appeal to authority” fallacy is claiming it to be true.

  5. Travis Lewis

    February 10, 2014 at 3:56 pm

    This post cites no sources on its claim about school choice – or even charter school -performance.

Check Also

Back to School Series – Our resilient students

This is part of a Back to School ...

Top Stories from NCPW

  • News
  • Commentary

When N.C. House Speaker Tim Moore and Senate President Pro Tem Phil Berger addressed reporters last [...]

Big corporations and wealthy executives have been on quite a run. Corporate profits are at historic [...]

This week the ACLU of North Carolina announced an initiative to end cash bail in North Carolina. Reg [...]

When Andrea Hudson was pulled over for a routine traffic violation in 2013, the police officer found [...]

There are a lot of important statistics that confirm just how out of whack the U.S. economy has grow [...]

The post Bite the Apple & NC’s HB2 Legacy appeared first on NC Policy Watch. [...]

When I headed off to college, I could not have predicted that many of the funding streams, positions [...]

For those who pay only periodic attention to the ins and outs of lawmaking in the North Carolina Gen [...]

Now hiring

NC Policy Watch is now hiring a Managing Editor – click here for more info.