Commentary

New data: In good times and bad, people are moving to NC

United Van Lines

Image: www.unitedvanlines.com

Politicians love to take credit for good things that happen while they are in office — whether they bear any real responsibility or not. As reported in this morning’s edition of the Weekly Briefing, North Carolina Lieutenant Governor Dan Forest, of all people, is even taking credit for the state’s falling unemployment rate and high rating in Site Selection magazine. As noted in the same space last month, however, the truth of such matters is a lot less clear cut:

“Except in times of profound crisis when extraordinary powers may occasionally be conferred, it is extremely rare that a political leader can do much more than make gradual tweaks and adjustments that will bear fruit (or not, as the case may be) somewhere down the road.

Meanwhile, the trends so busily tracked and catalogued by analysts each month – jobs, unemployment, incomes, retail sales, corporate profits and the like – are just as likely to be the byproduct of decades-long patterns (e.g. the exportation of jobs overseas and the evolution of the Internet) or recent unforeseen events (e.g. bad weather, a failed crop or a new invention) as they are of comparatively recent public policies like a new tax cut or a business incentive.”

New confirmation of this complex reality comes in the latest household moving numbers from United Van Lines. According to the just released annual study, North Carolina ranked Number 3 nationally of “top destination states.”

“Hmm, what’s this,” I hear you thinking, “real evidence that conservative leadership is turning things around in the Old North State?”

Not really.

It turns out that North Carolina has ranked near the top for several years — even during the depths of the Great Recession when the Dems were coming to the end of a long run in charge.

So, what’s up? Well, as noted above, like all things in the world of economics, it’s complicated. Many people move to a state because they have a job lined up, but many others move because they’ve heard jobs are more plentiful. Still others move because of the weather or the schools or the overall quality of life.

The bottom line lesson: Given the myriad complexities of what makes a state attractive to new residents and businesses, leaders would do well to recognize that North Carolina’s overarching status as a long-term magnet for growth is almost certainly the byproduct of decades of hard work and investments in constructing the infrastructure of a healthy state. This means good roads, good schools, a healthy environment, a good workforce and all the other things that make a place enjoyable to live in.

Except in boom and bust places dependent upon things like oil and gas prices, such reputations generally take years and years to build and last a long time once they’re constructed. Given this obvious truth, state leaders would do well not to get too caught up in the quick-fix gimmicks of the kind today’s Fitzsimon File discusses and to go easy on tearing down the basic structures and systems of government and public life that it took their predecessors decades to build.

4 Comments


  1. LayintheSmakDown

    January 7, 2015 at 10:33 am

    This lets you know that despite the hysteria of all the progressives, NC is being run well and an attractive place for people to settle. Thanks for the post, it is nice to see a positive post here once in a while.

  2. ML

    January 7, 2015 at 1:27 pm

    Not at all the point.

    Essentially, the rate of people moving to the state varies for many different reasons, least of which is who is currently in charge. Most important is the states reputation which takes years to build, that of course would be North Carolina’s southern progressive reputation following years of democratic rule. In our case it seems the current leadership hasn’t quite ruined our national reputation yet but it will once the perception of nc as a progressive state is over taken by the reality of our current leadership.

  3. Alan

    January 7, 2015 at 1:59 pm

    Well run my ***. We’re a national embarassment. No wonder Mercedes decided to skip NC for GA, can’t imagine too many businesses eyeing NC as a go-to state under this regime.

  4. LayintheSmakDown

    January 8, 2015 at 5:14 pm

    MB is going where the largest handout comes from, same as they did back when they were looking at Mebane for a factory.

Check Also

Join us next Monday for a Super Tuesday preview

Seats are still available for a very special ...

Top Stories from NCPW

  • News
  • Commentary

North Carolina House Speaker Tim Moore (R-Cleveland) is seeking the open chancellor’s position at Ea [...]

A public schools advocacy group is calling on North Carolina leaders to take “immediate and intentio [...]

"Satirical" Facebook site seeks to promote Trump's re-election When Jonathan Jones sa [...]

Not everyone in North Carolina understands the implications of court fines and fees and how expenses [...]

After a few months of unemployment I was going stir-crazy so I got a job as a cashier at a local gro [...]

Say this for North Carolina House Speaker Tim Moore and his surrogates, they are determined con arti [...]

The lengths to which conservative ideologues and members of the Trump cult will go in order to avoid [...]

The post Causey & effect (with Lt. Gov. Dan Forest) appeared first on NC Policy Watch. [...]