Lawmakers in Virginia’s General Assembly are advancing a bipartisan effort to abolish their A-F school grading system, according to WBDJ7 in Roanoke.
The A-F scale for schools was adopted in 2013 at the urging of then-Gov. Bob McDonnell, a Republican, as a public measure of school quality based on student test scores.
But the law was never implemented. The 2014 legislature delayed it two years.
On a 3-2 vote Monday, a Senate subcommittee endorsed Sen. Richard Black’s bill to abolish the A-F scale entirely. A similar measure is pending in the House of Delegates.
Black, a Loudoun County Republican, said he initially supported the grading scale but has become convinced that an F grade would stigmatize a school’s students and make it hard to recruit teachers. Democratic Gov. Terry McAuliffe’s administration supports repeal.
At a live taping of the weekly talk show NC SPIN this morning, panelists expressed concern with North Carolina’s own A-F school grading system, which assesses schools largely on the basis of how students perform on a single test given on one day, rather than the improvement a school makes over time.
Proponents of the A-F grading system, a policy initially launched in Florida under then-Governor Jeb Bush, say the grades allow parents to better understand how their children’s schools are performing. But critics say grading a school based on its students’ performance on a single test is not a good measure of success and worry that low-marked schools will experience negative long-term effects that include difficulty in attracting high quality teachers.
Rep. Craig Horn (R-Union) said this morning he endorses the grading system, but acknowledged that there are problems with its formula. Other panelists promoted changing the formula so that it was more heavily weighted toward improved student performance on assessments over time.
North Carolina will release A-F grades for its schools for the first time on February 5.