Just in: Federal judge finds no pattern of discrimination by Alamance County Sheriff

johnson_terryAlamance County Sheriff Terry Johnson did not engage in a pattern of discrimination against Hispanics, U.S. District Judge Thomas Schroeder has ruled in a 253-page decision just released.

The federal government had alleged that from 2007 to today, Johnson and his office had engaged in a number of discriminatory practices, as identified by the court in the decision, in violation of the Fourth and Fourteenth Amendments.

Principally, the Government charges that Alamance County Sheriff’s Office (“ACSO”) disproportionately subjects Hispanics to unreasonable searches, arrests them for minor infractions (in lieu of issuing warnings or citations), targets them at vehicle checkpoints located in predominantly Hispanic neighborhoods, uses ethnically-offensive epithets to refer to Hispanics and otherwise tolerates activities of deputies that evidence anti-Hispanic bias, automatically and selectively refers Hispanic arrestees to U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement  investigators for deportation, and otherwise engages in deficient policies, training, and oversight that facilitates discriminatory enforcement.

Schroeder found that the government had failed to introduce any evidence of individuals who were deprived of their constitutional rights and relied instead upon “vague, isolated statements attributed to Sheriff Johnson.”

And nobody testified that any ACSO employee carried out any improper directive or otherwise violated any individual’s constitutional rights, Schroeder noted.

“Indeed, all witnesses, including those called by the Government, denied that they ever did or knew any ACSO officer who did,” Schroeder wrote.

The judge also found that statistical analysis offered by the government was unreliable and not persuasive, “failing to sufficiently compare ACSO’s treatment of Hispanics to others who were similarly situated.”

Although ruling that the evidence of conduct by sheriff’s officers did not rise to the level of constitutional violations, Schroeder conceded that much of it was nonetheless troublesome:

While ACSO’s law enforcement practices do not constitute an unlawful “pattern or practice” of constitutional deprivations in violation of federal law, the court’s decision cannot be read to approve or condone all the conduct presented as evidence at trial. Indeed, some of it — for example, the use of ethnic slurs by a few officers largely in the County jail — demonstrated offensive and reprehensible activity that should not be tolerated in any civil society, much less in a law enforcement environment. Other evidence demonstrated potential internal weaknesses in ACSO, such as lack of a system to monitor selection of checkpoint locations, weakness in internal reporting and condemnation of conduct that violates ACSO’s internal policy manual, and a lack of substantive review processes for stops and post-stop outcomes. The absence of a finding of a violation of federal law should not be construed as approval of the status quo, and such matters deserve immediate attention.

For more on the case, read the story earlier this summer by Policy Watch’s Sarah Ovaska and this post on the filing of the complaint.

The full decision is here.

One Comment

  1. Kirk D. Smith

    August 7, 2015 at 6:10 pm

    Thank you for forcing the taxpayers to foot the bill on this witch-HUNT!

Check Also

State Supreme Court rules retroactive application of teacher tenure repeal is unconstitutional

The state Supreme Court ruled unanimously today that ...

Top Stories from NCPW

  • News
  • Commentary

The number of uninsured children in America increased by 726,000 between 2016 and 2019, reversing a [...]

Land ownership records, experiences elsewhere raise big questions as to where benefits from controve [...]

Republicans, including Tillis, endorse controversial nomination while Democrats express deep concern [...]

Schools in Wayne County were already struggling before COVID-19 When Wayne County Public Schools reo [...]

The post Rush to reopen schools driven by a noisy minority appeared first on NC Policy Watch. [...]

In a time of multiple and unprecedented challenges to individuals and societal well-being, our natio [...]

Potential demise of health care law leaves millions – especially women – on the brink The Affordable [...]

The U.S. militia movement has long been steeped in a peculiar – and unquestionably mistaken – interp [...]