Justice Edmunds recuses himself from challenge to retention election law

State-Supreme-Court-400As noted on the order sheet released today by the state Supreme Court, Justice Bob Edmunds has recused himself from taking part in the appeal concerning the new Supreme Court judicial retention election law.

Under that law, enacted in October and effective immediately, sitting Supreme Court justices running for re-election would be subjected to an up-or-down vote rather than face off against a challenger.

Edmunds is the only justice up for re-election and would have been the first to run without a challenger.


Critics of the law have said that Republican lawmakers pushed for an early effective date so as to give Edmunds an advantage and help ensure continued Republican control on the state’s highest court.

A three-judge panel struck down the new law  as unconstitutional in early March.  That ruling is now on appeal before the Supreme Court, which will hear argument on an expedited base, set for April 13, 2015.

In the interim, the state Board of Elections has opened up the filing period for challengers to the seat held by Edmunds, scheduling a primary election on the same date as congressional district elections, June 7.

The absence of Edmunds in the case raises the specter of a 3-3 split by the remaining justices, thus leaving the 3-judge panel ruling intact.

For more on the issues in the case, click here.



One Comment

  1. Laurie

    March 18, 2016 at 2:59 pm

    Wouldn’t all the justice’s have a vested interest in the case?

Check Also

State Supreme Court rules retroactive application of teacher tenure repeal is unconstitutional

The state Supreme Court ruled unanimously today that ...

Top Stories from NCPW

  • News
  • Commentary

Late March is prime spring planting season in North Carolina, and this year, as part of his personal [...]

The following collection of numbers comes from the 2018 North Carolina Child Health Report Card comp [...]

One-stop early voting for North Carolina’s May 8 primary election is a little over a month away, but [...]

A lone Southern yellow pine tree has stood in the middle of Marvin Winstead’s Nash County field for [...]

Ordinary Americans – those of us not allowed to know the secrets of high-level espionage work – at t [...]

Though they are sometimes dressed up in prettified language about “freedom” and “choice” and “market [...]

The post The apple doesn’t fall far from the tree appeared first on NC Policy Watch. [...]

In the aftermath of recent action by state lawmakers to back down from their previously enacted unfu [...]