Commentary

The next test for UNC’s President: Keeping politics out of science

The Wilmington Star-News lays it on the line today in its criticism of the North Carolina Policy Collaboratory, a legislative-inspired environmental think tank to be housed at UNC-Chapel Hill.

As the paper’s editorial board explains there may be good reason to be skeptical of the new center:

….it was created in this year’s budget to provide research into natural resource management and new technology to make the Tar Heel environment nicer. It’s also supposed to advise the General Assembly.

The legislature ponied up $1 million for the project for the next two years. The university system, apparently, is expected to come up with up to $3.5 million more from, well, somewhere.

Now, for professors, a brand new, shiny research institute is like a brand new video game for Christmas. Over in Chapel Hill, however, faculty member are dubious.

Spellings-and-Warren

UNC System President Margaret Spellings and Jeffrey Warren, Sen. Phil Berger science and energy advisor.

Why? Well, staffing of the Collaboratory is still supposedly up in the air, but word is, the new director is going to be Jeff Warren. Warren was science adviser to state Senate Republican leader Phil Berger. He was credited with writing the 2012 law that forbade state agencies from taking note of scientists’ predictions of sea level rise when drawing up coastal policy.

Berger, it happens, was one of the major sponsors of the Collaboratory concept. He’s gone on record as saying that the universities are all out of whack, with Democrats outnumbering Republicans by a 12-to-1 margin among faculty.

The suspicion is — and it’s a good one — that the Collaboratory will eventually turn into a think tank of tame scientists, who will come up with rigamarole to justify anything the Republicans in the legislature feel like doing.

Offshore drilling is good for fish and little children? Sure. Sea turtles spread the Zika virus? Durn straight. Let them bulldozers roll!

And the taxpayers will foot the bill.

The trouble is, scientists might be a bunch of wooly-headed liberals, but they also have this annoying habit of being right. Sea levels have been rising pretty much as Duke’s Orrin Pilkey said they would a quarter century ago.

Doctors said cigarette smoking caused lung cancer and heart disease. That was bad news for North Carolina’s tobacco industry, but as more folks quit smoking, tobacco-related lung cancer and heart disease rates plummeted.

Many politicians seem to think that reality is consensual. If your craven opponents say X equals Y, you find your own bunch of mouthpieces, label them experts and have them declare that, no, X equals Z.

These days, that’s a good way to win an election, but can be costly to make government policy this way. We need facts, genuinely unbiased facts.

This Collaboratory will be a major test for the new UNC president, Margaret Spellings. Let’s hope she gets it right.

Learn more about the man expected to head-up the North Carolina Policy Collaboratory in this piece by NC Policy Watch’s Lisa Sorg.

Read the full editorial here in the Wilmington Star-News.

One Comment


  1. Tony Dockery

    August 31, 2016 at 9:43 am

    A republican think tank?..hmmmm..heheh…heeheheh..hahahhahaahaha..More like a stink tank of arse gas and BS…More like a fact free zone….No thinking caps allowed…..

Check Also

The Week’s Top Five on NC Policy Watch

1. Democrats: Berger-Moore budget process may quash debate, ...

Top Stories from NCPW

  • News
  • Commentary

North Carolina election employees could soon be facing stricter scrutiny. House members rolled out a [...]

In one of the largest campaign donation forfeitures in state history, 48 improper donations from the [...]

Friends, neighbors, colleagues of commission chairman Jim Womack submit nearly identical letters cla [...]

When N.C. House Speaker Tim Moore and Senate President Pro Tem Phil Berger addressed reporters last [...]

In the aftermath of the recent successful push to ward off huge cuts to food assistance programs in [...]

There are a lot of important statistics that confirm just how out of whack the U.S. economy has grow [...]

The post Bite the Apple & NC’s HB2 Legacy appeared first on NC Policy Watch. [...]

When I headed off to college, I could not have predicted that many of the funding streams, positions [...]

Now hiring

NC Policy Watch is now hiring a Managing Editor – click here for more info.