News, Trump Administration

Report: Trump voucher plan could “decimate” traditional public schools

President Trump and U.S. Education Secretary Betsy DeVos

A new report from the progressive Center for American Progress says President Trump’s campaign call for $20 billion in federally-backed private school vouchers could have dire impacts for the nation’s traditional public schools.

While details of such a plan have been difficult to come by since his inauguration, expanding school choice options and vouchers is expected to be a major component of the Trump administration’s K-12 policy, particularly under controversial new U.S. Education Secretary Betsy DeVos.

But Friday’s report from a Washington, D.C.-based liberal think tank argues his voucher plan, one of Trump’s lone K-12 campaign promises, could destabilize many of the nation’s school districts, particularly thousands of the state’s smallest school districts.

From the report:

The findings underscore the severe limitations of President Trump and Secretary DeVos’ one-size-fits-all vision of nationalizing private-school vouchers. Public education in America is far from one-size-fits-all, and there is dramatic diversity within the more than 13,000 school districts across the nation—from the 1 million students in New York City’s more than 1,500 public schools, to the 60 students at the K-8 school on Beals Island, Maine, and its 100-student high school shared with the nearby town of Jonesport. Diversity can also be found among the 67 countywide districts in Florida educating more than 2.5 million students, the 545 districts in New Jersey educating nearly 1.3 million students, and the 413 districts educating fewer than 150,000 students in Montana.

When CAP staff members looked at the data, they found that there are:

  • Nearly 9,000 sparse school districts that have four or fewer schools where voucher proposals are highly unlikely to work and could decimate the public system
  • Another 2,200 average school districts that have five to eight schools where vouchers may not work and risk harming existing schools’ ability to serve millions of students

After excluding charter schools and regional agencies that are legally considered school districts, this means that 85 percent of the 11,200 regular school districts fall into these two categories of sparse and average districts where vouchers are entirely or more than likely to be unworkable as a logistical matter.

Private school vouchers have been a central plan of GOP-led school choice reforms across the country. Indeed, Republican leadership in the N.C. General Assembly plans to ramp up the state’s financial investment in vouchers by $100 million over the next decade, despite criticism that mostly religious private schools maintain discriminatory admissions policies toward other religions and LGBTQ students.

Nevertheless, North Carolina’s voucher movement has garnered traction with Republicans and a number of African-American Democrats in the legislature who say parents need more choices.

One Comment


  1. Michael Huston

    March 10, 2017 at 1:20 am

    This has got to be the stupidest argument ever.

    It’s saying that we have to maintain the government monopoly on the school system, which has been under attack for being overcrowded, understaffed, and providing, in most cases a low quality of education.

    If they implement a voucher system, the teachers’ unions will get the smaller class sizes they have been fighting for, but they will have to provide a higher quality of education.

    If they implement a standardized test, they don’t even need to spend any money making sure that the charter schools are towing the line.

Check Also

North Carolina teacher pay ranking to climb two spots in 2018, but still lags national average

North Carolina teacher pay is projected to climb ...

Top Stories from NCPW

  • News
  • Commentary

“I could choose to do anything else with $50.” But Anca Stefan, a high school English teacher in a D [...]

The Cape Fear River is damaged, contaminated by decades of human malfeasance, negligence and ignoran [...]

Legislative Services Officer Paul Coble appears to be violating the state public records law and is [...]

This morning, the state Supreme Court will hear oral arguments in the pivotal case of Silver, et al. [...]

These are extraordinary times in the American experiment with representative democracy. In Washingto [...]

Public education in North Carolina has its share of challenges, not the least of which has been the [...]

The post Time to come clean appeared first on NC Policy Watch. [...]

Tax Day in 2018 in North Carolina presents an opportunity to make sure our tax code allows us to mee [...]

Now hiring

NC Policy Watch is now hiring a Managing Editor – click here for more info.