Environment, Legislature

Sen. Cook complains about politics trumping science, then votes for leachate bill, backed by no science

Photograph of Senator Bill Cook of coastal North Carolina

Sen. Bill Cook, who represents eight coastal counties, said politics, not science, is influencing the Marine Fisheries Commission. (Photo: NC General Assembly)

The Senate agriculture and environment committee introduced a blizzard of last-minute, controversial amendments to a bill this morning — including one that state regulators had not even reviewed.

The NC Department of Environmental Quality “still has issues with” the Senate version of House Bill 56, said Andy Miller, DEQ’s legislative director.

One Senate amendment would strike language requiring facilities to notify the public whenever any amount of untreated wastewater is spilled into lakes, rivers and streams. Current law requires notice when the amount is 1,000 gallons. The amendment essentially maintains existing law.

Why are there changes to revert it back?” asked Democratic Sen. Angela Bryant, one of the few committee members who publicly quizzes the bill sponsors for explanations.

“Well, this goes on daily at municipal wastewater plants, at Duke Energy,” replied Sen. Andy Wells. “We know it’s going on.”

(Real Facts NC has video footage of this discussion.)

Arguably, it is not widely known how much untreated wastewater is discharged into surface waters and who is responsible for it.

Miller of DEQ could not comment to lawmakers about the amendment because, he said, “We’ve not been able to review it.”

Skeptical: Sen. Angela Bryant, a Democrat from northeastern North Carolina

Another amendment would reduce the number of seats on the Marine Fisheries Commission from nine to seven. The governor would still have the power to appoint the members, but like Republicans’ attempts to shrink the Court of Appeals and other governmental bodies they disagree with, this decrease is not as benign as it seems.

“In the last few years, most people believe the Marine Fisheries Commission has gotten out of control,” said Sen. Bill Cook, not defining “most people.” “They’re not basing decisions on science, but politics. Maybe this will encourage the commission to make better decisions.”

If that’s truly the case, then changing the statute to add scientists to the commission could solve the problem. Currently, there is only one: Mike Wicker, a biologist with the US Fish & Wildlife Service. His term expires on June 30, although Gov. Cooper could reappoint him.

“Most people,” it turns out, is the commercial fishing industry, which was upset over a recent commission decision to tighten trawling regulations. If the proposal survives public comment and rule-making, it would designate inshore waters as nursery areas and restrict the gear used by shrimp trawlers. The point of the proposed rule is to prevent fish from being unintentionally swept up in the trawlers; millions of pounds of fish are discarded but often die.

North Carolina Sportsman magazine reported last November that commercial fishers were also displeased with then-Gov. McCrory’s appointments. There are five people, including the  “at-large” seats, with recreational fishing/industry backgrounds, compared with three for commercial interests. And one lone scientist.

The amendment passed.

A new section appeared in HB 56, one that allows private out-of-state companies to use eminent domain to acquire land for the construction of natural gas pipelines. In-state companies can already have this power, but this provision is tailored to the Atlantic Coast Pipeline. Co-owned by Dominion, which is based Virginia, and Duke Energy, the ACP would run through environmentally sensitive and low-income, minority communities in eastern North Carolina.

The committee gave a favorable report to HB 56. It now goes to Senate Finance.

Science, while key to the decrease in fisheries commission members, had no bearing on the committee’s vote to approve HB 576, “Allow Aerosolization of Leachate.

Rep. Jimmy Dixon made a cameo appearance to again promote his bill, and again, sans proof, vouched for the scientific soundness of allowing landfill leachate to be sprayed into the air — without state water and air permits. He has repeatedly accused opponents of spreading false “trashy” misinformation about the technology.

Leachate aerosolization can spray thousands of gallons of wastewater per minute. (Screenshot from Kelly Houston’s leachate aerosolization website)

“We call this garbage juice in a snowblower,” said Brooks Rainey Pearson, an attorney with the Southern Environmental Law Center, one of many environmental groups opposing the bill.  “Maybe it is safe, but we don’t know. We can’t find any data confirming it’s safe.”

Depending on weather conditions and the size of particles, studies show these materials — viruses, bacteria and other toxins — can travel for several miles.

The leachate aerosolization equipment, invented and sold by Kelly Houston of Cornelius, costs about $120,000, according to a presentation by Republic Services, a solid waste company. Netting to contain the aerosol costs another $60,000. This is cheaper than pre-treatment systems, which Republic says cost $1.7 million, plus another $80,000 annually.

“Why don’t we allow DEQ to gather data?” Pearson continued. “If this technology is really safe, the backers wouldn’t have needed to come through you. You say this gives the industry certainty. It does. They don’t have to go through the permitting process.”

Dixon, who often speaks condescendingly to his adversaries, looked at Pearson and said: “Talk about false information, that’s a personification of it.”

The committee, including Sen. Cook, voted to give the bill a favorable report; it now goes to the Senate rules committee.

One Comment


  1. David Sneed

    May 31, 2017 at 8:57 pm

    The changes to the MFC will do nothing to improve our declining fish stocks. The only people upset with the current pro-resource Commission are commercial fishing interests. Connect the dots.

Check Also

Climate change throws shade on five vulnerable tree species in North Carolina

The Carolina Hemlock has enough problems. The tree, ...

Top Stories from NCPW

  • News
  • Commentary

More than a month after a deadline to correct faulty campaign finance reports, N.C. Sen. Ralph Hise [...]

Even before he dropped the gavel on the Senate Finance Committee meeting, Sen. Jerry Tillman, a noto [...]

The $23 billion budget deal speeding through the N.C. General Assembly this week includes a platoon [...]

Royal Diadem Jewelers in Greensboro sets itself apart in a number of small ways - fast and friendly [...]

The final budget that lawmakers have proposed fails to strengthen the foundation of North Carolina’s [...]

Most of the initial headlines about the final budget agreement announced Monday afternoon by legisla [...]

Unexplained, backroom maneuver would rob already underfunded anti-poverty program There’s no denying [...]

Women and their access to health care has been in the news these past few months, as the plan to rep [...]

Featured | Special Projects

Trump + North Carolina
In dozens of vitally important areas, policy decisions of the Trump administration are dramatically affecting and altering the lives of North Carolinians. This growing collection of stories summarizes and critiques many of the most important decisions and their impacts.
Read more


HB2 - The continuing controversy
Policy Watch’s comprehensive coverage of North Carolina’s sweeping anti-LGBT law.
Read more