Environment

Comment period ends Aug. 19 on state’s water permit for Atlantic Coast Pipeline; plus a look at who’s in the blast zone

Vibrina Coronado, a member of the Lumbee Tribe: “The route of the ACP is through native nations. Rural, native, low-income people shouldn’t be disproportionately affected.” Thirteen percent of the population affected by the ACP is American Indian, even though they compose only 1.2 percent of the population statewide. (Photo: Lisa Sorg)

The NC Department of Environmental Quality is accepting public comment until Aug. 19 at 5 p.m. on the Atlantic Coast Pipeline’s application for a water quality certification and buffer authorization. This is known as a 401 certification.

Submit comments by email with “ACP” in the subject line: PublicComments@ncdenr.gov

O n three of the four corners of Whistling Rufus and Philadelphus roads on the outskirts of Pembroke sit a smattering of homes of varying ages and conditions. On the northwest corner, a stark, modest two-story with a child’s slide in the back yard; to the northeast, a one-story ranch where the crape myrtles are blooming in brilliant hues of magenta and pink; and to the southwest, a mishmash of buildings, including a mobile home with foil covering its front windows to block out the morning sun.

All of these houses share at least one commonality: They lie within the blast zone of the Atlantic Coast Pipeline, where people would likely be injured or die in the event of a natural gas explosion.

Clean Water for North Carolina issued a report this week with maps showing the most vulnerable areas in seven of the eight counties along the 160-mile portion of the route in eastern North Carolina. Meanwhile, BREDL (Blue Ridge Environmental Defense League) sent a letter to the state fire association detailing the causes of the 1,329 pipeline accidents over the past 20 years — including corrosion and welding failures — and the resulting risk to both rural North Carolina and first responders.

 

The Final Environmental Impact Statement for the ACP identified 24 High Consequence Areas in North Carolina. Of the eight counties along the route, all but Sampson have at least one of these areas: they have at least 20 occupied buildings or “vulnerable populations” — daycare centers, retirement homes.

In addition to these High Consequence Areas, ACP contractors, hired by Duke Energy and Dominion Energy, calculated a Blast Zone of 660 feet, based on the pipeline’s 36-inch diameter and the pressure per square inch. But Oshin Paranjape, who is pursuing her master’s degree at the Duke University Nicholas School of the Environment, reviewed the contractors’ technical documents on behalf of Clean Water for North Carolina. Based on that data, Paranjape calculated the Blast Zone is 943 feet — about a third larger than ACP contractors figured. The evacuation zone is 3,071 feet, more than a half-mile from the radius.

That means at the corner of Whistling Rufus and Philadelphus roads, the home with the child’s slide and the ranch with the crape myrtles are within the blast zone, as are many houses to the north. The mobile home with the foil covering the windows, the Green Pine Free Will Baptist Church and buildings to the south lie within the evacuation zone, assuming the wind is blowing away from it.

 

In red, the blast zone near Whistling Rufus and Philadelphus roads in Robeson County located at the intersection near the middle of the image. The yellow lines signify the pipeline route and survey area. The light pink designates the evacuation zone. Clean Water for North Carolina’s report contains maps of all blast and evacuation zones associated with the ACP’s route in the state. (Image: Clean Water for North Carolina)

 

C lean Water for North Carolina’s and BREDL’s reports coincided with the state’s final public listening sessions about the effects of the pipeline on water, wildlife habits and forests; plus environmental justice and economic issues of the $5.5 billion project. After DEQ held public hearings on the water quality issues, Secretary Michael Regan added three more listening sessions in Nash, Northampton and Robeson counties, and invited additional state agency representatives from Indian Affairs, Commerce and Natural and Cultural Resources, to attend.

Chief Deputy Secretary John Nicholson said the sessions were added because other concerns regarding economic benefits, environmental justice and tribal lands had emerged during the initial hearings.

Lumberton held the last of the three sessions. Here, state officials heard from members of the Lumbee tribe, as wells as environmental advocates from Sustainable Sandhills and private citizens — all of whom opposed the ACP — and who recommended that the state prioritize renewable energy instead.

Hydrologist Ryan Emanuel is a 10th-generation Lumbee and associate professor at NC State University. He cited the climate change impacts caused by fossil fuels like natural gas. Every degree above normal will cost the US 1 percent of its gross domestic product. In North Carolina, that translates to $4 billion annually. “Why are we here discussing water quality permits when the scientific communities says we should be moving away from this project as fast as we can?”

The environmental justice assessment was flawed and designed to fail Click To Tweet

He also criticized the ACP’s Final Environmental Impact Study on social justice grounds. “The environmental justice assessment was flawed and designed to fail,” Emanuel said, adding that he sent a detailed analysis, vetted by editors at science journals, to federal regulators. “All eight tribes” in North Carolina met with state and federal regulators, he said, “and roundly criticized the failure to engage us early in the process.”

The American Indian Council, Emanuel said, “wants to stop these permits until there is proper engagement.”

Ryan Emanuel, a 10th-generation Lumbee, is a professor and hydrologist at NC State University. He argued against the ACP on scientific and environmental justice grounds. In the background is Sarah Rice, who oversees DEQ’s environmental justice programs. (Photo: Lisa Sorg)

Vibrina Coronado, who is Lumbee, is not within the evacuation but has family and friends who are. They live near Prospect, where the ACP will connect with a Piedmont gas pipeline and continue through Richmond and Scotland counties to the South Carolina border. She is especially concerned about the ability o firefighters to respond to a leak or explosion. Neither Duke nor Dominion will pay a special fire tax to fund more firefighters or equipment. “This is on the shoulders of the local firefighters,” Coronado said. “They get no direct benefit from this facility.”

Opponents question whether the ACP is even necessary, considering there is already a pipeline serving eastern North Carolina: the Transcontinental, which runs west to east and cuts through Hamlet in Richmond County. The ACP would also cut through Hamlet. And the ACP would largely serve Duke and Dominion’s own electricity-generating plants; only a small portion of the gas, federal documents say, would directly service neighborhoods or industry.

“Eastern North Carolina is completely out of the way, ” said the Rev. Mac Ledgerton. To avoid the environmental, public safety and social justice issues in eastern North Carolina, he said, additional lines could be built parallel to, or spurring from, the existing TransCo line. “But Duke and Dominion don’t own TransCo,” Ledgerton said. “They want a new one of their own.”

There's no guarantee I'd wake up the next morning. Click To Tweet

Chambers of Commerce and elected officials along the route support the pipeline because, they say, the additional natural gas would help attract industry to economically stressed eastern North Carolina. However, there are no firm estimates on how many companies would locate in this part of the state for that reason. And ratepayers would bear the cost of the pipeline construction.

Tom Clark, hoisting a 36-inch diameter hoop to illustrate the size of the pipeline, challenged the purported economic benefits. He questioned whether the environmental and public health risks were worth 20 permanent positions and 400 temporary construction jobs that would likely go to locals in eight counties, according to ACP documents. The other 400 would go to out-of-state workers.

Clark lives near the route. In the pipeline documents, he said, “I’m called a sacrifice.” If a pipeline explosion were to occur, he added, “there’s no guarantee I’d wake up the next morning.”

 

 

2 Comments


  1. Vibrina Coronado

    August 19, 2017 at 4:37 pm

    Please correct the spelling of my name–it’s Vibrina Coronado. Thanx

  2. richard manyes

    August 20, 2017 at 7:38 am

    Do you really think this pipeline isn’t going through? Do you not realize how close Duke is with Cooper? Remember when Cooper made loud noises about getting shareholders to pay for coal ash – now that the rate hikes are coming in, have you seen Cooper anywhere? The same is true here. Back when Cooper was going after TVA (very ineffectively as it turned out) that was purely to keep Duke’s rates competitive by forcing TVA to increase their costs. Duke wants this pipeline – Duke gets this pipeline.

Check Also

Illegal oil and gas commission postponed, one statement of economic interest still missing

The state oil and gas commission, which had ...

Top Stories from NCPW

  • News
  • Commentary

This story has been updated with comments from Jim Womack, who did not respond earlier to questions. [...]

For the 18 months, Gary Brown has been traveling through northeastern North Carolina like an itinera [...]

It will be at least another month before state Superintendent Mark Johnson can take over at the helm [...]

Eric Hall, in the midst of a rainy drive to rural Robeson County to pitch North Carolina’s ambitious [...]

5---number of days since Senators Bill Cassidy and Lindsey Graham unveiled a new proposal to repeal [...]

The post The stench of hate speech appeared first on NC Policy Watch. [...]

When a Navy recruiter visited his high school, Carlos was among those students eager to sign up. In [...]

Website with ties to Civitas Institute promotes anti-Semitic attack on Attorney General Stein There [...]

Featured | Special Projects

NC Budget 2017
The maze of the NC Budget is complex. Follow the stories to follow the money.
Read more


NC Redistricting 2017
New map, new districts, new lawmakers. Here’s what you need to know about gerrymandering in NC.
Read more