Commentary

Latest GOP redistricting plan: Same ol’, same ol’

As reporter Melissa Boughton explains this morning over on the Policy Watch homepage in “North Carolina voters give lawmakers tongue-lashing over new proposed legislative maps,” the latest maps concocted by Republican gerrymanderer-extraordinaire, Tom Hofeller were given a richly-deserved thumbs-down yesterday by citizens around the state.

“North Carolina voters’ message to lawmakers Tuesday evening was clear: they’re unhappy with their representatives and they’re unhappy with the new proposed legislative maps.

Hundreds of speakers across the state attended public hearings to speak about the maps, which were released over the weekend as a remedy to correct unconstitutional racial gerrymanders.

Most of the people who spoke were disappointed that, according to demographic information released Monday, lawmakers appeared to trade in racial gerrymandering for partisan gerrymandering.”

An editorial in this morning’s edition of Raleigh’s News & Observer helps explain why so many are rightfully disgusted:

“As he does so often, Bob Phillips, head of Common Cause in North Carolina, had it exactly right with his comments on some pitiful, harshly partisan legislative districts as redrawn by Republican lawmakers, or rather by their hired consultant.

Made necessary by federal court rulings that found some of their 2011 districts to be racially gerrymandered, the new maps – likely in a drawer for some months while the court cases played out – continue to skew districts toward Republicans. That was entirely expected, since the rules for new maps the GOP leaders made for themselves allowed partisan consideration and voting patterns to be used in the new districts. Phillips, long an advocate of nonpartisan redistricting – done after every 10-year census – said GOP lawmakers blew a ‘golden opportunity to adopt fair, nonpartisan standards’ for districts. Instead, he found ‘partisanship at the core,’ and that’s right.

Making things worse is that by calculation, GOP leaders have offered the public a very limited amount of time to comment and offer input on the maps. In reality, of course, Republicans couldn’t care less about what the public thinks, which is the point of not allowing them time to offer their own opinions. If they did, they’d likely state the obvious: Why not form a nonpartisan redistricting commission to draw new maps and avoid what has been a huge public expense as Republicans have tried to defend the indefensible in federal court, to no avail?

Now, of course, Republicans are taking a chance that their maps will again be found to be gerrymandered in the extreme by the courts, at which point the courts would come in and draw the maps.

This story has been like the maps themselves – twists and turns and misdirection and confusion that do no favors for the fair democratic process in which people should vote for their representatives based on geographical good sense and competing ideas, not on ridiculously-drawn districts designed to give Republicans an advantage in keeping control of the General Assembly. If Republicans believe so strongly in their ideas, they should not fear a fair competition. But they do.”
Let’s hope the federal judges reject the latest scheme and put someone in charge who will finally give our state some fair maps.

Check Also

Columnist debunks myth-making by Forest, Troxler on industrial hog farms

Be sure to check out columnist Ned Barnett’s ...

Top Stories from NCPW

  • News
  • Commentary

As part of an ongoing effort to inform North Carolinians about the upcoming judicial elections, Poli [...]

As part of an ongoing effort to inform North Carolinians about the upcoming judicial elections, Poli [...]

As part of an ongoing effort to inform North Carolinians about the upcoming judicial elections, NC P [...]

Lack of implementing language in amendment legislation raises additional concerns When the General A [...]

The post It’s getting deep… appeared first on NC Policy Watch. [...]

Six years ago, long before #AbolishICE, and long before Immigrations and Customs Enforcement (ICE) a [...]

Few times in recent memory have demanded a more careful examination of our nation's history tha [...]

Suicide prevention was a major issue during the 2017-18 legislative session of the North Carolina Ge [...]