Commentary

The best op-ed of the morning: Cardinal is what you get by privatizing mental health services

Be sure to check out a fantastic op-ed in this morning’s edition of Raleigh’s News & Observer by Durham clinical social worker Barbara Smith. In “Managed care failed, now rebuild N.C.’s mental health care system,” Smith does a great job of telling it like it is when it comes to North Carolina’s failed, decades-long privatization scheme in the provision of mental health services. Here central thesis: abandoning a system of publicly-run, brick and mortar community health centers throughout the state in favor of a system of regional, privately-run “managed care” operations (like the one run by the greedy money grabbers at Cardinal Innovations) has been a disaster that has put money-making above serving people in need. As Smith explains:

North Carolina had a good community mental health system, built in the 1970s and 1980s as a product of a progressive movement in the state. Every county had its own mental health center, or joined forces with neighboring counties. Brick and mortar buildings served anyone who needed help. The community mental health centers were part of one public mental health system. They could share information with each other and with the state psychiatric hospitals and UNC Hospitals.

Then, she explains, came the transition to privately run “managed care.” Soon, she notes, hospital “emergency rooms overflowed with people who needed behavioral health services.”

Here’s her fine conclusion:

“Here’s what managed care does: It makes it harder to get care. It sets up hoops for providers to jump through, first to become a provider in a closed network, and then to complete the paperwork needed to get authorizations for services. Cardinal Innovations wielded considerable power – it controlled the flow of funding to treatment and service providers.

Frontline mental health workers – the people who actually deliver mental health care – saw their salaries go down. Many lost benefits and job security. The first workers to be let go in the streamlined private agencies were clinical supervisors – experienced psychologists, clinical social workers and psychotherapists who trained new workers and provided ongoing supervision. The drive for productivity in the private agencies is relentless; it’s the only way to make the business model work.

Unlike the community mental health system, which served all comers, the new system is only for Medicaid recipients, with paltry funding for those with no insurance. It’s not easy to get Medicaid, especially in a state that did not accept the expansion under the Affordable Care Act. Many with great need are left out entirely.

So what’s next? Gov. Roy Cooper, the Department of Health and Human Services and the General Assembly have a responsibility to do right by our most vulnerable residents, and by taxpayers. We have considerable expertise in this state around best practices in behavioral health. Let’s hope that in the aftermath of the unraveling of Cardinal Innovations, we can rebuild a behavioral health system that is truly person-centered, is integrated with the broader health system, and is guided by proper oversight of public resources. The private sector does many things well – but is it the right vehicle for providing care to our vulnerable citizens?”

2 Comments


  1. Barbara

    December 16, 2017 at 10:00 am

    Thanks so much for sharing my piece!

  2. Patti Ulirsch

    December 16, 2017 at 10:47 pm

    This is spot on! Why can’t our legislators learn instead of planning on taking this travesty even further by privatizing all of Medicaid within a couple of years? This Cardinal debacle exemplifies why privatization should be scrapped. Managed care and privatization entities become mindless gatekeepers who limit access and quality of care; more layers of administrators are added at the top while direct care professionals and those who receive needed services become thebottom of the food chain. A top down approach does a disservice to those with disabilities and to the people who care for them while simultaneously squandering our state tax dollars on the greedy, entitled class extremely personified by Richard Topping at Cardinal and his lieutenants.

Check Also

Report: GOP tried to speed up vote after learning of second (and third?) Kavanaugh accuser

Ian Millhiser of Think Progress filed this commentary ...

Top Stories from NCPW

  • News
  • Commentary

Last week Hurricane Florence crippled much of Southeast North Carolina. This week, as Governor Roy C [...]

Hurricane Florence has laid bare the environmental justice issues that are often masked by sunny new [...]

It’s still not clear exactly how much damage Hurricane Florence left in her wake, but "the show [...]

When the Silent Sam Confederate Statue was toppled at UNC-Chapel Hill last month, a flurry of text m [...]

The post In search of a bright side… appeared first on NC Policy Watch. [...]

As an OB/GYN caring for the women and families of North Carolina, I know abortion is a safe, essenti [...]

It’s a truism that weather affects elections. Yes, many of us would slosh through a downpour if that [...]

To this point, everything about Brett Kavanaugh -- from his indoctrination in  Kenneth Starr's [...]