Courts & the Law, Defending Democracy, News

The opinions: SCOTUS punts two partisan gerrymandering cases

The U.S. Supreme Court passed on its two opportunities this term to weigh in on partisan gerrymandering.

Opinions in two pending cases — Gil v. Whitford and Benisek v. Lamone — were released this morning.

Gil was mostly dismissed for lack of standing and sent back to the lower court “so that the plaintiffs may have an opportunity to prove con­crete and particularized injuries using evidence — unlike the bulk of the evidence presented thus far — that would tend to demonstrate a burden on their individual votes.”

Chief Justice John Roberts wrote the opinion about Wisconsin’s challenge to a 2011 state legislative redistricting map drawn by its Republican-controlled legislature. Justices Anthony Kennedy, Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Stephen Breyer, Samuel Alito, Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan joined. Justices Clarence Thomas and Neil Gorsuch concurred except for part III, which is the part that remands the case back to the lower court.

Kagan wrote a concurring opinion that Ginsburg, Breyer and Sotomayor joined, and Thomas wrote an opinion concurring in part that Gorsuch joined.

In Benisek, the Justices unanimously affirmed a lower court’s decision not to issue a preliminary injunction in a Maryland case that contended congressional redistricting targeted a Republican in violation of the First Amendment.

You can read both full opinions below. An analysis of the opinions and what they could mean for North Carolina will be available this afternoon at NC Policy Watch.

Gil v. Whitford by NC Policy Watch on Scribd

Benisek v. Lamone by NC Policy Watch on Scribd

Check Also

NC Board of Elections votes to make Circosta new chair

Perhaps the fourth North Carolina Board of Elections ...

Top Stories from NCPW

  • News
  • Commentary

Last week Robin Jordan shared her experience at a field hearing on Medicaid expansion organized by N [...]

Every year, North Carolina removes registered voters from its voter rolls as part of a maintenance r [...]

Numerous questions remain, however, about the treatment of dozens of other trans inmates Kanautica Z [...]

The Trump Administration’s new public charge rule will do more to keep families separated than it wi [...]

If there is a single brightest and most hopeful bit of news on the North Carolina public policy hori [...]

Thirty-two seconds. That’s how long it took for the madman responsible for the carnage in Dayton, Oh [...]

It can’t have escaped many folks’ notice – even those, bless their hearts, for whom the really big n [...]

Today we wait. We wait for the judges, who retired to their chambers weeks ago in the Common Cause v [...]