Commentary

Friday likely to be the acid test for Sen. Thom Tillis

Sen. Thom Tillis

Friday may well mark the single most important day in the political career of North Carolina’s junior senator Thom Tillis. That’s the day that U.S. Senate Republicans have indicated they intend to have the Senate Judiciary Committee vote on the nomination of Brett Kavanaugh to serve a lifetime appointment on the U.S. Supreme Court. The announcement of the planned vote comes, remarkably, despite the fact that the committee is also scheduled to hear that very same day from one of two women who have come forward to accuse Kavanaugh of what amount to sexual assaults when he was a young man.

By every indication, it appears that Senate Republicans will, without even seriously considering the testimony of Dr. Christine Blasey Ford, dismiss her claims, ignore widespread calls for a full investigation and move rapidly forward to place Kavanaugh on the Court. If this, in fact, the case, it is hard to overstate what a treacherous, immoral and Machiavellian move it will constitute.

Of course, merely to vote on the nomination is not to approve it. Confirmation will require “yes” votes from all 11 Republicans on the committee — a group that includes Mr. Tillis. If any Republican votes “no,” the nomination will fail in committee.

It’s fair to say then that one of the most important congressional votes in modern American history rests on Tills’s shoulders. The senator can do the right thing, stand up for basic human decency and vote “no” on Kavanaugh, or he can refuse to rock the boat, go along with the flow like so many drunken prep school party boys apparently did at Yale and Georgetown Prep back in the 1980’s and vote “yes.”

The implications for Tillis’s political career are, of course, significant. If he summons his inner manhood and defies Republican leaders, he’ll undoubtedly face a far right primary opponent in 2020 (though that eventuality may already be likely). If, on the other hand, he meekly shuffles along with the GOP pack, he will hand any Democratic challenger a huge and powerful issue with which to attack and defeat him.

But, of course, the truly important thing here is not Tillis’s career. Rather, it is our country’s future and whether it can find a way out of the dark tunnel of corruption, racism, misogyny and lawlessness that are the hallmarks of the Trump presidency.

Throughout his career, Thom Tillis has attempted to portray himself as an arch-conservative, but not an unreasonable ideologue. And on occasion — with respect to immigrants, some aspects of Trump corruption and, recently, climate change — Tillis has, at least partially, lived up to this claim and shown himself to be willing to do and say the right thing, even if it means defying the far Right.

This Friday, however, will provide an acid test that will quickly overshadow his stances on any of those other issues. If he says “no” to rushing Kavanaugh through, he will reveal himself to be a man of some measure of principle and validate his past claims to being an independent thinker and leader. It will be an act by which he will be long remembered.

If, however, he meekly assents to the GOP power play, all those claims of independence will be revealed to be a fraud. He will, instead, be remembered as a loyal party hack and a politician who cared more about his own career than truth and justice.

4 Comments


  1. Eugene W. Moore

    September 26, 2018 at 5:54 pm

    Well written post concerning Tillis, Rob. A fair statement in clearly identifying how much of an “independent” Tillis really is as he represents NC in the US Senate.

  2. Bob Hamilton

    September 27, 2018 at 1:05 am

    You can email Tillis at this address:

    http://www.tillis.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/email-me

    Let him know WE ARE WATCHING.

    Bob

  3. Kathy

    September 27, 2018 at 6:45 pm

    Doing the right thing is neither political expediency nor betrayal. It is simply doing the right thing. Tillis just did the right thing with his personal minutes in the hearing. The Republicans are clarifying this afternoon how the Democrats botched the opportunity to investigate Dr Ford’s allegations in a timely fashion. Today’s Lesson yet to be learned by Democrats: the Senate Judiciary Committee IS THE BODY RESPONSIBLE FOR INVESTIGATING allegations against a judicial nominee.

  4. Bev Slagle

    September 27, 2018 at 7:03 pm

    Great job senator Tillis! I’m very proud to be a Republican tonight, and proud of you as my senator. As usual, you laid it out clearly and consistently. Kavanaugh should be confirmed.

    Bev Slagle

Check Also

Another editorial pleads with Burr, Tillis to end ideological attack on federal courts

As Clayton Henkel noted yesterday, the Winston-Salem Journal ...

Top Stories from NCPW

  • News
  • Commentary

Shortly after 10 o’clock yesterday morning, a federal jury in the hog nuisance case Gillis vs. Murph [...]

North Carolina state law would seem to provide just two options for Wayne County school leaders, clo [...]

Perhaps the sixth time is the charm? Rep. David Lewis (R-Harnett) unveiled another attempt Tuesday b [...]

As the UNC Board of Governors prepares to take up the fate of the Silent Sam Confederate monument Fr [...]

Fayetteville is my hometown more than any – I was born here to military parents, this is where my gr [...]

It’s long been understood by those who pay attention to public policy debates that the age-old conse [...]

The post The newest nuisance in the 9th: Election Fraud Scandal appeared first on NC Policy Watch. [...]

Earlier this week, the UNC-Chapel Hill Board of Trustees (BoT) began plans to erect a statue dedicat [...]