Education

Teacher lunch bill approved by House K-12 Education Committee

A bill to give teachers a 30 minute, duty-free lunch every day received a favorable hearing in the House K-12 Education Committee on Tuesday.

The bill will now go to the House Rules Committee.

Rep. Craig Horn, (R-Union), one of House Bill 563’s co-sponsors, said teachers could receive a much-needed break during the school day if the bill is approved.

“Just some private time or a break in the middle of the day,” Horn said. “How much more can we ask of our teachers than we already ask?”

N.C. Rep. Craig Horn, R-Union

Horn, a co-chairman of the Education Committee, introduced the bill for primary sponsor Rep. John A. Torbett, a Gaston County Republican.

Torbett attended Tuesday’s meeting but left for another engagement before HB 563 was discussed.

Horn said HB 563 is needed because teachers get little alone time during the school day.

“We ask so much of them and they get virtually no privacy from the moment they leave their house in the morning, their phone’s ringing, until they get back at night and their phone continues to ring,” Horn said.

Although the bill was broadly supported, committee members had questions about language that appears to make the duty-free lunch optional for districts.

They also noted that the bill had no funding attached, which could cost districts that abide by the law.

“I don’t think any of us could disagree conceptually with the idea this bill represents, but I do have one question related to whether this is in the nature of an unfunded mandate,” said Rep. Hugh Blackwell, (R-Burke).

Blackwell said districts would have to hire someone to watch students while teachers eat lunch.

“I’m just wondering if there’s a cost implication for the LEA [Local Education Agency or school district],” Blackwell said. “If we’re mandating they’ve got to do it, who’s going to pay for the additional staff.”

No money has been committed to the bill, but committee staffers pledged to check for available funding.

The state law that covers school improvement plans would be rewritten to include the 30 minute requirement for a duty-free lunch.

The committee approved an amendment brought forth by Rep. Ashton Wheeler Clemmons, (D-Guilford), which mirrors language in state law governing teacher’s instructional planning time.

The language states that duty-free instructional planning time “shall be provided to the maximum extent that safety and proper supervision of children may allow during regular student contact hours and insofar as funds are provided for this purpose by the General Assembly.”

“That’s the same language that holds us as school systems accountable for duty-free instructional planning, said Clemmons, adding that duty-free lunch should have the same expectation.

Rep. Marvin W. Lucas, (D-Cumberland), said the language gives school districts wiggle room.

“That could be away for LEAs to say, you know, we can’t afford to allow you to eat with those circumstances, so therefore, you can’t have it,” Lucas said. “That worries me.”

Rep. Larry Potts, (R-Davidson), said HB 563 could place a burden on the state’s large school districts.

“This could run into a lot money if everybody in instruction has to have a duty-free lunch,” Potts said.

He said it will be difficult to support HB 563 without a plan to pay for it.

Under House Bill 563, teachers would get a minimum of 30 minutes each day to eat without having to supervise students, perform other tasks such as lunch duty or attend required meetings.

Ample time for a meal and lesson planning are real issues for teachers who often complain they don’t get enough time to do either during the course of a school day.

Teachers say lunch and instructional planning time is often interrupted by meetings or is lost entirely when teachers must use planning periods to fill in for absent colleagues because substitutes aren’t available.

Teachers responding to a social media query about where they currently receive 30 minutes for lunch shared varied experiences. While some teachers routinely get 30 minutes or more for lunch, others say they barely get a minute or two to “woof” down a meal.

“We get 25 minutes duty free for lunch … but it came at the expense of our planning period being cut shorter,” Sherry Vestal, a Randolph County teacher, wrote on the North Carolina Teachers United Facebook page.

The social media query by N.C. Policy Watch prompted nearly 400 comments, which shows how strongly teachers feel about receiving a lunch break during the school day.

Katherine Victoria, a former Transylvania County Schools teacher now working in Roseburg, Oregon, said teachers in Oregon receive 40 minute, duty-free lunches.

“I left NC for a unionized state and the grass is GREENER! 40 min duty free lunch is part of my contract. It’s never been taken, but if it were, I’d be paid (what is equivalent to) my hourly rate at time and a HALF,” Victoria wrote on the North Carolina Teachers United Facebook page.

When asked who watches students during lunch by a North Carolina educator, Victoria said aids and assistants serve as lunchroom monitors.

She said aids and assistants are pulled from kindergarten, first-grade and interventions to monitor the cafeteria and playground.

“Lunch and recess happen consecutively, 20 min each to allow for our 40 min lunch break,” Victoria wrote.

2 Comments


  1. Stephanie Stephens

    April 18, 2019 at 8:51 am

    If no money is allocated to fund this and/or it is not clearly worded as a mandate (with no loopholes for LEAs) then it’s a waste of everyone’s time. We can’t legislate with merely good intentions. There must also be a clear and viable action plan to support the law. Otherwise, it will just sound good…all talk with no action.

  2. Jean Brown

    April 19, 2019 at 8:05 am

    Hire an assistant for each teacher k. thru 2nd grade. They take their teacher class to lunch stay with them. This give the teacher free lunch time. After that the assistant will eat lunch. Problem solved.

Check Also

Teachers stand with Gov. Cooper despite veto risking pay raises for 2019

It’s looks like North Carolina educators won’t get ...

Top Stories from NCPW

  • News
  • Commentary

When it began in 1919, it was “Armistice Day” — a celebration of the end of World War I. It became a [...]

Peter Romary worked for UNC board member Tom Fetzer, but claimed connections to Senate leader Phil B [...]

GREENSBORO – A Pender County graduate almost missed an opportunity to pursue his dream job because h [...]

Lawmakers criticize probe as "threat to academic freedom" U.S. Rep. Andy Levin (D-Michigan [...]

Back in the early 1990’s, the late and sorely missed Bob Hensley – a talented, feisty and frequently [...]

The post Berger on shaky ground appeared first on NC Policy Watch. [...]

Today marks 100 days since I filed an official request with the Department of Public Instruction to [...]

Yesterday, the North Carolina Supreme Court considered whether immigrants detained unlawfully under [...]