Courts & the Law, Defending Democracy, News

BREAKING: Republican attorneys send legislature prohibited partisan data during remedial mapmaking

The law firm representing Republican legislative leaders in an ongoing partisan gerrymandering case may have just polluted the remedial mapmaking process by sending them partisan data prohibited from use. 

A court last week ordered lawmakers to draw new House and Senate maps after they used unconstitutional partisan gerrymandering to create the 2017 legislative maps, diluting Democratic voting strength. They have 10 days to enact new districts.

The redistricting committees from both chambers met today for the first time to begin the process. They had decided to use baseline maps produced by a plaintiffs’ expert in Common Cause v. Lewis, Jowei Chen.

Chen created 2,000 simulated maps for each chamber for the two-week Common Cause trial — 1,000 maps using only traditional redistricting criteria and 1,000 maps using that criteria and taking incumbency protection into account. Lawmakers did not have the maps and asked both their counsel and the plaintiffs’ counsel for the information.

Chen agreed to send the appropriate map data to lawmakers Monday evening, but in the meantime, Ogletree Deakins — the law firm for the defense — sent the experts’ original files, which contain extensive partisan data, including the partisan scoring of the simulated maps, according to an email sent to the legislature.

The court expressly prohibited lawmakers from using or considering any partisan data at all in the remedial process.

Attorneys for the plaintiffs asked legislative staff to immediately delete the email containing the partisan data and to destroy the data if they already downloaded it. The email also asks staff to inform the plaintiffs if the information was shared with anyone.

The email from Ogletree Deakins was sent just after 4:20 p.m. Monday, and it was sent to all members of the House redistricting committee in addition to legislative staff. The email response to the legislature from the plaintiffs’ attorneys was sent about 20 minutes later. It’s not clear if the initial email containing the partisan data was an accident or intentional.

Both committees remain in recess, but are expected to return shortly. Follow reporter Melissa Boughton on Twitter for live updates.

One Comment


  1. Marsha Hammond PhD

    September 10, 2019 at 6:41 pm

    Great detail writing. This being said, I might think your readers, whom might be the public and not legislators who live and breathe partisan map-making, could benefit from some background info. I don’t know how you get this in but here are some basic questions that arose for me as I read and I have kept up with this more than 99% of NC citizens:
    1. Where are Chen’s baseline maps?
    2. What is a baseline map?
    3. What is “incumbent protection.” as re: info included (how included?) as per some of Chen’s maps.
    4. Seems to me that would serve the GOP and be partisan—-which is what these efforts purport to NOT be about—-as they are the supramajority.
    5. What is partisan scoring?
    6. How is/ who determined partisan scoring?
    7. Whats the verdict as to whether partisan data maps being shared “accidentally” or not?
    8. What could be the purpose of such sharing?

    Feel free to pass this around. Marsha V. Hammond, PhD, Licensed Psychologist, Asheville NC

Check Also

Report: NC receives failing grade in response to COVID-19 in jails

In a report released this month, the ACLU ...

Top Stories from NCPW

  • News
  • Commentary

WASHINGTON — After the Republican National Convention pulled out of Charlotte earlier this year due [...]

[Editor's note: As a part of an ongoing effort to help North Carolina voters become better info [...]

The number of uninsured children in America increased by 726,000 between 2016 and 2019, reversing a [...]

Land ownership records, experiences elsewhere raise big questions as to where benefits from controve [...]

If the Trump Administration and a group of 18 states convince the Supreme Court to strike down the A [...]

In the 16 years I’ve lived in this exact spot, I’ve been no stranger to disaster. It’s been two year [...]

It’s been seven months since the COVID-19 pandemic turned life upside down in North Carolina, but it [...]

[Editor’s note: The Senate Judiciary Committee is expected to vote on President Trump’s nomination o [...]