In a one-sentence order and without dissent, the U.S. Supreme Court late yesterday denied a request by a Kentucky county clerk for a stay of orders requiring her to perform marriages as part of her job duties, pending her appeal on the merits to the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
The Rowan County Clerk, Kim Davis, stopped issuing any marriage licenses shortly after the high court’s decision in Obergfell v. Hodges in order to avoid doing so for same-sex couples — which she said would violate her religious beliefs.
A federal district court judge in Kentucky, David L. Bunning, ruled that Davis either had to start issuing marriage licenses to all couples or resign, and the Sixth Circuit refused to block that order while it considered the underlying merits of her appeal, saying that it found “little or no likelihood that the clerk in her official capacity [would] prevail” on those merits.
As SCOTUSblog’s Lyle Denniston noted yesterday, the request “mark[ed] the first time that the Court has been asked to take any action on the spreading resistance, based on religious opposition, to the June 26 ruling opening marriage rights to same-sex couples.”
State lawmakers here codified that right to refuse based upon religious objection this session when it enacted the magistrate’s refusal bill, Senate Bill 2 — over a veto by Gov. Pat McCrory.
Justice Elena Kagan, who handles emergency filings from the Sixth Circuit. referred the request to the full court, which then issued the order.
Read the Kentucky clerk’s full application in Davis v. Miller here.