Dell plant closing despite $280m in potential subsidies: We told you so.

Dell Computers, Inc. has announced that it will shutter its Winston-Salem plant over the next few months, laying off all of the factory’s 905 workers. With roughly six applicants for every opening in the current job market the re-employment prospect for these workers is bleak. Out of respect for these workers and their families and to prevent this from happening again in the future the state should seriously consider enacting major reforms to its business subsidy programs. There are already a few good places to find recommendations for how to make NC’s subsidy deals more accountable and more effective (hyperlinks to these reports below).

In media reports about the closing representatives site the steep decline in desktop sales as the chief reason. That may be true but consider the fact that in determining how much to award to Dell in state subsidies the factor that weighed most heavily was, in fact, sales projections. This flaw in the state’s economic model (relying much too heavily on what company sales might be 5, 10, and even 15 years down the road) is the most serious flaw in the state’s method for determining how much to offer companies. To read more about these flaws and others, and to see more details about the assumptions the state made about the Dell facility, read our report from 2007, “GETTING OUR MONEY’S WORTH? An Evaluation of the Economic Model Used for Awarding State Business Subsidies.”

In addition to overhauling the ecomomic model used to determine the optimal bids for these deals, the state needs to substantially increase the wage standards for the subsidized jobs (Dell got a $280 million deal despite only paying its workers on average $28k per year) and target subsidies to distressed areas. Coincidentally, these recommendations were made earlier this year by UNC faculty researchers in their report to the North Carolina General Assembly Select Committee on Economic Development Incentives.


  1. Dell Computers locks up again | theCLog

    October 8, 2009 at 4:51 pm

    […] jobs to distressed areas — which at this point, is most of the state. Read all about their ideas here. var linkwithin_site_id = 37835; (function () { var elem = document.createElement('script'); […]

  2. Lane Sarver

    October 9, 2009 at 11:56 am

    Although it makes us “shudder” to consider how much tax money went into this fiasco, Dell is actually going to “shutter” the plant, which I guess means closing the blinds once and for all. At least the closing is “transparent”.

Check Also

A public success story: North Carolina’s older adults are far less likely to live in poverty

According to data released last week by the ...

Top Stories from NCPW

  • News
  • Commentary

Fifty-one duplicate invoices. At least $20,000 in excess payments. And one nonprofit receiving a dis [...]

WASHINGTON -- Sen. Thom Tillis made a stunning reversal on Thursday, declaring he would support Pres [...]

Rainwater monitoring conducted by state environmental regulators show one detection of a type of per [...]

North Carolina lawmakers are debating two proposals that would direct state money to fund long overd [...]

The post Profiles in courage…and cowardice appeared first on NC Policy Watch. [...]

It’s Sunshine Week, and things have never been gloomier for the newspaper industry. This year’s annu [...]

Gov. Roy Cooper is an enormously skilled politician with a top-flight staff and many years of experi [...]

The post For a few dollars more… appeared first on NC Policy Watch. [...]