Commentary

Drug testing “welfare” applicants turning out to be the giant waste that critics foresaw

This afternoon’s “must read”:

Drug testingThe results are in: North Carolina’s law to drug test Work First applicants is a costly and mean-spirited waste of time

By Mike Meno, ACLU-NC Communications Director

Early results of a new law that allows North Carolina to drug test people who apply for Work First, a program that provides temporary assistance to needy families, confirm what the ACLU-NC and others argued at the time of the bill’s passage: it is a wasteful and unnecessary government invasion of vulnerable people’s privacy.

The law was originally passed in 2013, over the veto of Gov. Pat McCrory, who called the measure “a recipe for government overreach and unnecessary government intrusion” that “is not a smart way to combat drug abuse.”

According to the Department of Health and Human Services, the state has spent about $5,500 to review 7,600 applicants between August and December. About 2 percent of the applicants were referred for a drug test, and of those, 21 people tested positive. That amounts to less than 0.3% of all applicants, according to the News & Observer. Put another way, North Carolina spent about $262 for each applicant it “caught” testing positive.

These numbers show once again that people seeking temporary assistance to support their families are no more likely to use drugs than the general public, and that laws that single out and stigmatize vulnerable people with invasive and constitutionally suspect drug tests are nothing more than a mean-spirited waste of taxpayer dollars.

The people who benefit from Work First’s temporary cash assistance, job training, and support services – and therefor most at risk under this law – are primarily families. In about 62 percent of cases, Work First benefits go to children. Of the 21 cases that tested positive for drugs, 12 involve children. Those families will now receive reduced support, and need to pay $55 for a second test if they want to reapply.

It’s important to remember in these cases that drug tests are notoriously faulty, and that if individuals are in need of drug treatment, cutting off or reducing aid to their families usually does little to get them to the help that they need. Whether it’s student loans or Social Security, many people receive some type of government benefit, yet North Carolina singles out only these vulnerable families trying to make ends meet for this unnecessary and demeaning scrutiny.

North Carolina’s lawmakers should end this misguided and baseless targeting of Work First applicants and give them the same respect and privacy they would anyone else.

2 Comments


  1. Laurie

    February 10, 2016 at 3:47 pm

    The wisdom of investing a dollar to save a penny. Fiduciary Responsibility is not our current Legislature’s strong suit.

  2. Janet Jenkins

    February 11, 2016 at 2:03 pm

    How do you take a sample group (those “referred” or 89 people) of 2%, have 23% (21 people) of the sample group test positive, and then translate that to .003 of all respondants (7600 people)? Check your math. Those testing positive cannot extrapolated back into the entire group population (welfare applicants) and be found to be the ONLY applicants in violation. The methodology for selecting the 2% for sampling/testing is inconclusive because unless it is random, it shows bias.

Check Also

Breaking: Cooper vetoes abortion bill

Gov. Roy Cooper vetoed Senate Bill 359 this ...

Top Stories from NCPW

  • News
  • Commentary

Kenneth Dodge, one of the nation’s preeminent scholars on early childhood education, says North Caro [...]

The North Carolina General Assembly has spent the past few years making a concerted effort to impose [...]

Of all the enemies to single out, conservative lawmakers have targeted nature — the wind, sun and tr [...]

Greear Webb and Myles Cyrus would have made great student advisers to the State Board of Education ( [...]

North Carolina’s dubious ranking of having the 10th highest rate of uninsured people in the nation c [...]

There are a lot of important public policy issues right now in North Carolina on which right and lef [...]

We know Sen. Phil Berger, perhaps the most powerful lawmaker in North Carolina politics, can speak. [...]

Today is Tax Day. It’s a day that many Americans have come to instinctively dread, but here are a co [...]