Commentary

Editorial: The Gorsuch debacle spirals to a disastrous conclusion

Raleigh’s News & Observer does a fine job this morning of exploring and explaining the depths to which yesterday’s detonation of “the nuclear option” by U.S. Senate Republicans in order to confirm Neil Gorsuch to the Supreme Court takes our politics. After exposing the utter absurdity of the refusal to confirm President Obama’s nominee, Merrick Garland, the editorial rightfully decries the idea of altering decades-old rules to help, of all people, Donald Trump:

“Now, in changing the Senate rules to prevent a filibuster of President Trump’s nominee for the court, conservative federal Judge Neil Gorsuch, the GOP guarantees Gorsuch a seat. And, Republican senators in using the ‘nuclear option’ of a majority-only requirement for approval, reject the very logic they used against Garland, that the people through their votes would let it be known what kind of justice they wanted. By that logic, the people wanted Garland, because three million more of them voted against President Trump than for him.

This is a sorry day indeed for democracy, and Mitch McConnell, the hard-line Republican leader from Kentucky who signaled his ardent dislike for President Obama from the beginning of his two terms as the elected president of the United States, offers ridiculous logic for his maneuver. He said Democrats kept ‘raising the stakes and moving the goalposts’ and that ‘we need to restore the norms of the Senate.’ What?

The ‘norms’ would have required a vote on Garland; the ‘norms’ would have left in place the requirement that a nominee have 60 votes to avoid filibuster. McConnell is the one who ‘moved the goalposts,’ and he knows it.

So Trump will have his justice in Gorsuch, 49, who absent the Garland fiasco might be more easily accepted by Democrats, as the party not in the White House generally respects the choice of the elected president, even if the president’s choice would not be that of the other party.

Regardless of his personal character, which is strong, Gorsuch will take his seat under a cloud Republicans seeded. They’ve set up a scenario wherein future presidents who may not be to their liking can nominate liberal ideologues Republicans may despise, but the simple majority required for confirmation will allow that future president to do as he or she wishes without the advice of the Senate.

Gorsuch wins. Almost everyone else, and most certainly the credibility of the Senate leadership, loses.”

Check Also

More editorials: Nonpartisan redistricting commission a must

After watching what’s been going on in the ...

Top Stories from NCPW

  • News
  • Commentary

Future of once-powerful congressional group in question as "Trump whisperer" takes his lea [...]

Civil rights litigation isn’t always about securing a win in court – sometimes there is a deeper rec [...]

Thom Goolsby, a former North Carolina state Senator now serving on the UNC Board of Governors, is ru [...]

Duke Energy calls its new net-zero carbon emissions plan a "directional beacon," but for c [...]

It’s September and America’s school children are back in class. They’re greeted every day with the u [...]

Powerful new research confirms numerous benefits of substantially increasing public investments For [...]

The confluence of three essentially unprecedented events combined to make last week an extraordinary [...]

The post The two faces of the NC GOP appeared first on NC Policy Watch. [...]