Courts & the Law, Defending Democracy, News

Anita Earls sworn in as new Supreme Court justice in standing room only ceremony

Anita Earls was sworn in Thursday as a new justice on the state Supreme Court. Here she chats with individuals at a reception in her honor at the old state capitol. (Photo by Melissa Boughton)

The newest state Supreme Court Justice Anita Earls had a swearing in ceremony Thursday afternoon that drew a crowd of North Carolina’s biggest movers and shakers in both the legal and legislative world.

Earls wore a classic black skirt suit with an airy white blouse and a shiny gold and silver floral broach pinned onto the middle of her collar. She had the state Supreme Court seal pinned to her lapel. Her big smile was shining; her happiness oozed, and the hugs she gave the people in the room were genuine — it was not the state many are used to seeing her in, particularly in the courtroom. As an attorney, Earls was always the epitome of buttoned up and professional, remaining cool, calm and collected even during what could be perceived as intimidating moments.

Her ceremony attendance list was a long one; more than 300 people RSVP’d to the event, and there were at least three run-off rooms for the crowds that could’t make it to the main Supreme Court courtroom. Attendees included John Edwards, Attorney General Josh Stein, former Chief Justices Henry Frye and Sarah Parker, Gov. Roy Cooper, Patricia Timmons-Goodson, Federal Judge James Wynn, former Justices Bob Edmunds and Bob Orr and many, many legislators.

Per tradition, Barbara Jackson, who lost the race in the midterm to Earls, did not attend the event.

Earls was described by colleagues and friends at the event as esteemed, incredibly hard working and wholly devoted to equal access to justice, and they put their full faith in her. Her election tips the Supreme Court to a 5-2 Democratic majority.

She has a prestigious background with varied experience and is known prominently for her civil rights work. She also founded the Southern Coalition for Social Justice (SCSJ), of which Kareem Crayton is now the interim director.

“There simply would not be an SCSJ without the vision, energy, and commitment of Anita Earls to build an organization that has become a key force in effort to make the South a more equal, just and inclusive place for its citizens,” he said after her ceremony. “Thousands of people across this region are better off today because of the work she has led.”

Crayton said they remain grateful for all that Earls has done, and he congratulated her on a “remarkable achievement.”

Earls, who is the 100th Supreme Court justice, vowed to pull through on her promises to the state. She also spoke about why the job is so important to her.

“Growing up in the time and place that I did, as a young girl, I believed it was my responsibility to bring together my family, my community and my country across the racial lines that divided us” she said during her remarks. “Indeed, I saw that my life, my very survival depended on it.”

She feared her family would be torn apart, and believed she had to bring everyone together to show shared humanity and guarantee equal opportunities for all.

“Now I understand so many years later that bringing us together across all the lines that threaten to divide us: race, gender, ideology, wealth, among others, I understand that no one person can do it alone. It will take changes in our culture. It is influenced by the millions of choices that we all make every day. And it will take all of our countries, public and private institutions, to affect that healing, to bring us together for the common good, to lift us up instead of tearing each other apart. And it requires a system of justice that adheres to the rule of law, a system of laws and institutions to enforce them — they genuinely and with intellectual honesty aspires to equal justice. A system in which no one is above the law, and justice does not depend on gender, wealth, status, political party, race, creed or color. The cases that come before this court impact individual people’s lives in profound ways and have wide-ranging effects on the future of this state. I pledge to give every case full and fair consideration. My personal commitment is to serve justice with a strong heart.”

Below are some of the photos from her event:

Now-Justice Anita Earls talks with her husband during a swearing in ceremony Thursday. (Photo by Melissa Boughton

A Supreme Court justice claps on Anita Earls at her swearing in ceremony Thursday (Photo by Melissa Boughton)

Gov. Roy Cooper sat next to Anita Earls on Thursday at her swearing in ceremony. (Photo by Melissa Boughton)

Former state Supreme Court Chief Justices Sarah Parker and Henry Frye chat after Justice Anita Earls’ swearing in ceremony. (Photo by Melissa Boughton)

State Supreme Court Justice Anita Earls chats with former presidential candidate John Edwards at a reception in her honor. (Photo by Melissa Boughton)

Jane Pinsky takes a photo of new Justice Anita Earls at a reception at the old state capitol. (Photo by Melissa Boughton)

New Justice Anita Earls talks with new Durham District Attorney Satana Deberry. (Photo by Melissa Boughton)

5 Comments


  1. Patricia Voss

    January 5, 2019 at 8:10 am

    Why was it necessary to describe what Justice Earls was wearing? Her qualifications and experience are why she was elected. It’s 2019, I thought we’d gone past defining women by their appearance or their clothes, but I apparently we haven’t. I’m disappointed.

  2. Cassandra Woodhouse

    January 6, 2019 at 10:02 am

    In an otherwise respectful and celebratory commentary on Anita Earls’ swearing-in ceremony, there was a lengthy and puzzling description of Justice Earls’ airy white blouse, shiny jewelry, shining big smile, and happiness that oozed.
    So, why not a review of John Edward’s impeccably tailored suit, boyish good looks, and $400 coiffure?

  3. Melissa Boughton

    January 7, 2019 at 10:30 am

    I am the author of this story, and a woman. The description of Justice Earls’ clothes was in no way an effort to distract from her impeccable background. This was her ceremony and she was glowing, from what I can only assume is pure joy from celebrating her incredible accomplishment. I thought that was worth writing about, just as we have more frequently written about her achievements in the state. NC Policy Watch has also written about men’s clothing in the past as well, and I urge you to read about that for context: http://www.ncpolicywatch.com/2017/03/03/larry-hall-wins-unanimous-committee-approval-veteran-affairs-post/ and http://www.ncpolicywatch.com/2018/11/16/high-powered-trial-lawyers-joust-as-latest-hog-trial-commences/

  4. Gretchen M Engel

    January 7, 2019 at 2:16 pm

    I agree with the commenters that leading off with a description of Justice Earls’ clothing was inappropriate. Whether the author intended to distract from Justice Earls’ background, it did exactly that. I found it demeaning, infuriating, lazy, and embarrassing, all the more so because of the placement and amount of time devoted to her appearance. Meanwhile, her incredible record of public service and advocacy as a lawyers for 30+ years was reduced to “She has a prestigious background with varied experience and is known prominently for her civil rights work. She also founded the Southern Coalition for Social Justice (SCSJ).” As to the articles about men’s clothing, Larry Hall talked about his clothing at the event and his “Marine red” jacket was related to his ascendancy to the post of Cabinet Secretary for Veterans Affairs. Given the history of media focus on women’s bodies and appearance, seems to me we should be careful about writing about it, even if there is occasionally some mention of some guy in a starched shirt. It would have been easy enough to talk about Justice Earls’ joy and beaming face w/o going into her jewelry, etc.

    Also, weird not to identify Samuel J. Ervin, IV as the “clapping justice” or to refer to John Edwards as a former Senator.

  5. JOHN GROOMS

    January 7, 2019 at 6:29 pm

    I’m an old white guy, liberal as all get out, former Vietnam War protester, participant in the 1968 Poor People’s March, first male feminist I ever knew, former alt weekly editor and columnist, blahblahblah, so I qualify as a member of this site’s regular readership. OK, so there. I want to say I agree completely with the complaints here regarding the highlighting of Judge Earls’ attire at her swearing in ceremony. In fact my initial, instinctive reaction to the description was “WTH is this, an article from Redbook magazine”? Luckily, the story got down to business later but wow, Not the needed intro.

Check Also

Judges appoint referee in partisan gerrymandering case; give lawmakers 1 more day to make maps

The three-judge panel in North Carolina’s ongoing partisan ...

Top Stories from NCPW

  • News
  • Commentary

State environmental regulators will have the power to require most composting facilities to test for [...]

A few short years ago, Lakewood Elementary School in Durham was a low-performing school where only o [...]

[Editor's note: In an extraordinary move unprecedented in modern state history, a narrow quorum [...]

The North Carolina General Assembly is embarking on a historically transparent redistricting process [...]

Surrounded by the labyrinthine performance metrics of North Carolina’s charter school sector, Commen [...]

Nomination of longtime conservative financier and partisan as possible referee makes clear that GOP [...]

If politics can be described as a contact sport, it’s perhaps fitting to say that when the Republica [...]

The post Lady Justice finally has her say on gerrymandering appeared first on NC Policy Watch. [...]