More editorials: Nonpartisan redistricting commission a must

After watching what’s been going on in the House and the Senate the last few weeks, editorials from across the state are making a stronger case than ever for removing the authority for drawing legislative maps from the state legislature. On Friday, a Capitol Broadcasting Company editorial on put it this way:

Legislators proved they are not to be trusted to objectively draw election district lines. At a minimum, their self-interest – regardless of partisanship — to make their own re-election as assured as possible makes them unable to develop fair and impartial maps as defined by the court.

Even though the court said legislators could not use political or voting data in their work, they could consider incumbency. That was the small opening needed to perpetuate their hyper gerrymandering….

Using incumbency – with its legacy in illegal gerrymandering – provide the excuse and means to perpetuate the problem the court wanted fixed. These legislators know the composition of their districts intimately, precinct by precinct. They intuitively know the partisan behavior even if they can’t see the exact data…..

The lesson here is simple. It can be addressed right away. Legislators lack the ability – either because of their own incumbency or partisan bias – to draw election districts that put the interests of voters and representation of communities first. Only imposition of a non-partisan system will fix it.

And this is from this morning’s Winston-Salem Journal:

…the division and the deception and the quest for world domination by Republicans now — and the Democrats before them — need to end. The redrawn districts will be a start.

Whatever the final outcome, they should be an improvement over what we have.

Better yet would be maps drawn by an independent commission.

We can only hope. It would be nice to see a sense of fairness in elections, versus manipulation and self-interest.

These two come on top of last week’s entry from the Charlotte Observer and News & Observer entitled “NC’s new voting maps have already failed” which put concluded this way:

…we believe the court should wrest the maps from the hands of lawmakers and either give the task to a special master or, if there’s time before 2020, allow lawmakers to pursue an independent commission that would produce N.C. districts not colored by partisanship and self-interest. Lawmakers have had their chance, for decades and again this month. They’ve failed.

And this morning’s editorial cartoon from John Cole of Policy Watch sums things up neatly:


  1. Marsha Hammond

    September 24, 2019 at 1:28 pm

    No excuses. Let’s have non- partisan maps for 2020.

    Time for the GOP to stop whining, crying, bellyaching, pointing at someone else as the problem, and bullying. Keep your grubby, incumbent hands off our maps.

    That’s quite an assortment of personality characteristics, said this psychologist. Gee,who does it remind me of? The fish rots at the head.

  2. George Greene

    September 25, 2019 at 8:30 am

    No it isn’t. A non-partisan tedistricting commission is not a must. It may not even help.
    What guidelines or criteria will it be using? Whatever they may be, anyone could use them. If they are not the right criteria, then they can still produce unfair districts, even It Never Matters WHO is doimg ig — it mayyers WHAT they are doing.

Check Also

NC Policy Watch to host Charlotte Crucial Conversation on future of school integration

Join us Wednesday, October 30 for a very ...

Top Stories from NCPW

  • News
  • Commentary

North Carolina Republicans are using procedural arguments to dismiss the relevance of the U.S. House [...]

A troubled charter school in the Rowan County town of East Spencer has turned to a man with a checke [...]

Nearly half of the female students at UNC-Chapel Hill have experienced some form of sexual assault b [...]

Despite concerns, Treasurer Dale Folwell maintains state investments in much-criticized company that [...]

When the journalist Michael Kinsley wrote in 1984 that a gaffe “is when a politician tells the truth [...]

Tonight's Democratic presidential debate will be dominated by two urgent issues: the House of R [...]

Supporters of public education fight back against empty promises of state’s school privatization mov [...]

Survey of hold-out states indicates the Medicaid expansion debate has entered a new phase Across the [...]